Indian Contract Act, 1872 | Landmark Cases | LawFoyer

43 Landmark Cases on the Indian Contract Act, 1872 | LawFoyer
LF LawFoyer
LawFoyer legal research library · India

Indian Contract Act, 1872
Landmark Cases

A comprehensive topic-wise study of 43 selected judgments, with precise issues, judicial holdings, relevant provisions and full-text sources.

43 cases10 themesUpdated 16 November 2026
LawFoyer Indian Contract Act 1872 landmark cases, with scales of justice and law books

Case-law research desk

Search the entire compilation by case, principle or section. Results stay grouped by doctrinal topic.

Showing all 43 cases
No judgments match. Clear the filters or try a different keyword.
01 / 10

Offer, acceptance and concluded contracts

Offers must be effectively communicated and accepted. Courts examine assent, not merely the document title.

Offer, acceptance and concluded contractsCASE 01

Bhagwandas Goverdhandas Kedia v. Girdharilal Parshottamdas & Co.

AIR 1966 SC 543 · Supreme Court of India · 1965

Legal issue. Where does a contract made by telephone come into existence?

Ratio. For instantaneous communications, acceptance is effective when communicated to, and received by, the offeror. Telephone contracts differ from acceptance by post.

Read facts, significance and research notes

Material facts

The parties negotiated a transaction over a long-distance telephone call and disputed jurisdiction.

Why this case matters

Foundational authority on Sections 3 and 4 and contracts through instantaneous communication.

Relevant provisions

Sections 2, 3, 4

Source description

Supreme Court judgment, public full-text reproduction. Decided 30 August 1965.

Offer, acceptance and concluded contractsCASE 02

Kollipara Sriramulu v. T. Aswathanarayana

AIR 1968 SC 1028 · Supreme Court of India · 1968

Legal issue. Can an oral bargain bind parties where a formal document remains unsigned?

Ratio. An oral contract is effective where essential terms are settled and execution of a later writing was not intended as a condition precedent.

Read facts, significance and research notes

Material facts

Co-owners agreed orally to sell shares in property, while contemplating later documentation.

Why this case matters

Tests whether parties reached consensus, rather than merely planning documentation.

Relevant provisions

Sections 2, 10

Source description

Supreme Court judgment, public full-text reproduction. Decided 4 March 1968.

Offer, acceptance and concluded contractsCASE 03

Brij Mohan v. Sugra Begum

(1990) 4 SCC 147 · Supreme Court of India · 1990

Legal issue. What proof establishes a concluded oral contract for sale of immovable property?

Ratio. An oral contract can be valid; however, the person seeking enforcement carries a heavy burden to prove agreement on all fundamental terms. The result turned on the evidence of the alleged terms.

Read facts, significance and research notes

Material facts

Purchasers sought specific performance based on conversations and incomplete documentation.

Why this case matters

Provides the practical evidentiary limit to Kollipara Sriramulu.

Relevant provisions

Sections 10, 13

Source description

Supreme Court judgment, public full-text reproduction. Decided 19 July 1990.

Offer, acceptance and concluded contractsCASE 04

Dresser Rand S.A. v. Bindal Agro Chem Ltd.

(2006) 1 SCC 751 · Supreme Court of India · 2006

Legal issue. Does every letter of intent conclude a binding contract?

Ratio. A letter of intent normally signals a future contract, but can itself amount to acceptance if its terms demonstrate final, unconditional assent.

Read facts, significance and research notes

Material facts

The parties exchanged bidding documents and letters of intent for equipment purchases.

Why this case matters

Essential case for tenders, letters of intent, and preliminary commercial documents.

Relevant provisions

Sections 2, 7, 10

Source description

Supreme Court judgment, public full-text reproduction. Decided 12 January 2006.

Offer, acceptance and concluded contractsCASE 05

Trimex International FZE Ltd. v. Vedanta Aluminium Ltd.

Arbitration Petition No. 10 of 2009 (SC) · Supreme Court of India · 2010

Legal issue. Can email exchanges create a binding agreement without a signed final contract?

Ratio. Clear acceptance of material terms through correspondence can form a binding contract, even where parties expect a later formal document.

Read facts, significance and research notes

Material facts

Parties negotiated bauxite supplies by email, accepted commercial terms, and later disputed whether agreement existed.

Why this case matters

Important to electronic contracting and arbitration clauses agreed through correspondence.

Relevant provisions

Sections 4, 7, 10

Source description

Supreme Court judgment, public full-text reproduction. Decided 22 January 2010.

02 / 10

Consideration, privity and reliance

Valid consideration differs from privity; reliance-based remedies have their own statutory and equitable tests.

Consideration, privity and relianceCASE 06

Masum Ali v. Abdul Aziz

(1914) ILR 36 All 268 · Allahabad High Court · 1914

Legal issue. Is a bare promise to donate enforceable?

Ratio. A merely gratuitous subscription promise was unenforceable on these facts, in the absence of legally sufficient consideration or action founding liability.

Read facts, significance and research notes

Material facts

Contributors made promises towards repairs to a mosque, but the works had not commenced.

Why this case matters

Illustrates the requirement of consideration for ordinary gratuitous promises.

Relevant provisions

Sections 2(d), 25

Source description

Reported judgment, public full-text reproduction. Decided 11 March 1914.

Consideration, privity and relianceCASE 07

M.C. Chacko v. State Bank of Travancore

(1969) 2 SCC 343 · Supreme Court of India · 1969

Legal issue. Can a stranger to a contract enforce its covenants?

Ratio. As a general rule, a person who is not party to an agreement cannot sue upon it; recognised exceptions include trust beneficiaries and qualifying family arrangements.

Read facts, significance and research notes

Material facts

A bank sought to enforce arrangements made between family members against one recipient of property.

Why this case matters

Clarifies that third-party consideration differs from the doctrine of privity.

Relevant provisions

Section 2(d)

Source description

Supreme Court judgment, public full-text reproduction. Decided 23 July 1969.

Consideration, privity and relianceCASE 08

Union of India v. Indo-Afghan Agencies Ltd.

AIR 1968 SC 718 · Supreme Court of India · 1967

Legal issue. Can the Government resile from a trade-policy representation relied upon by exporters?

Ratio. Government representations made for reliance may attract equitable enforcement; executive discretion cannot alone defeat a clear promise.

Read facts, significance and research notes

Material facts

Exporters acted on a representation regarding import entitlement certificates and received a reduced benefit.

Why this case matters

Foundational Indian judgment on governmental promissory estoppel, distinct from ordinary contractual consideration.

Relevant provisions

Equitable promissory estoppel

Source description

Supreme Court judgment, public full-text reproduction. Decided 22 November 1967.

Consideration, privity and relianceCASE 09

State of Punjab v. Nestle India Ltd.

(2004) 6 SCC 465 · Supreme Court of India · 2004

Legal issue. When does governmental promissory estoppel protect taxpayers?

Ratio. The Court examined the representation, reliance and statutory power to grant relief. Promissory estoppel remains subject to statutory prohibitions and overriding equity.

Read facts, significance and research notes

Material facts

Milk-processing businesses relied on official announcements of a purchase-tax concession.

Why this case matters

Useful synthesis of the scope and limits of reliance-based enforcement.

Relevant provisions

Equitable promissory estoppel

Source description

Supreme Court judgment, public full-text reproduction. Decided 5 May 2004.

04 / 10

Lawful objects, public policy and restraint of trade

A bargain can fail because its object, content or restrictive effect conflicts with law.

Lawful objects, public policy and restraint of tradeCASE 14

Gherulal Parakh v. Mahadeodas Maiya

AIR 1959 SC 781 · Supreme Court of India · 1959

Legal issue. Does every void wager make a collateral transaction illegal?

Ratio. A wagering agreement is void under Section 30 but not automatically forbidden by law for Section 23; a collateral agreement was not invalid solely for that reason.

Read facts, significance and research notes

Material facts

The dispute concerned a partnership intended to transact in wagers.

Why this case matters

Explains the distinction between void agreements and unlawful objects, subject to other applicable gambling laws.

Relevant provisions

Sections 23, 30

Source description

Supreme Court judgment, public full-text reproduction. Decided 26 March 1959.

Lawful objects, public policy and restraint of tradeCASE 15

Central Inland Water Transport Corp. v. Brojo Nath Ganguly

(1986) 3 SCC 156 · Supreme Court of India · 1986

Legal issue. Can a grossly unfair employment term be rejected as contrary to public policy?

Ratio. The Court struck down the unconscionable rule in a setting of substantial inequality of bargaining power; it also addressed Article 14.

Read facts, significance and research notes

Material facts

A government-controlled corporation relied on a service rule allowing termination on three months’ notice.

Why this case matters

Leading authority on oppressive standard-form clauses, subject to the facts and nature of bargaining power.

Relevant provisions

Section 23; Constitution Article 14

Source description

Supreme Court judgment, public full-text reproduction. Decided 6 April 1986.

Lawful objects, public policy and restraint of tradeCASE 16

Superintendence Co. of India (P) Ltd. v. Krishan Murgai

(1981) 2 SCC 246 · Supreme Court of India · 1980

Legal issue. Can an employer enforce a post-employment restriction on competing work?

Ratio. The Supreme Court refused interim enforcement; the scope and construction of the restrictive wording were material. The opinions also addressed Section 27.

Read facts, significance and research notes

Material facts

An employee faced an injunction application founded upon a restrictive employment covenant.

Why this case matters

Read with later decisions on non-compete restrictions; do not assume every during-term restriction is void.

Relevant provisions

Section 27

Source description

Supreme Court judgment, public full-text reproduction. Decided 9 May 1980.

Lawful objects, public policy and restraint of tradeCASE 17

Gujarat Bottling Co. Ltd. v. Coca Cola Co.

(1995) 5 SCC 545 · Supreme Court of India · 1995

Legal issue. Are exclusivity obligations during a bottling agreement necessarily restraints of trade?

Ratio. A negative covenant operating during the subsistence of a lawful collaboration may protect and advance its purpose; its enforceability depends on context.

Read facts, significance and research notes

Material facts

A bottler agreed not to handle competing drinks during the subsistence of its licensing arrangement.

Why this case matters

Key contrast with restrictions extending beyond the contract’s duration.

Relevant provisions

Section 27

Source description

Supreme Court judgment, public full-text reproduction. Decided 4 August 1995.

Lawful objects, public policy and restraint of tradeCASE 18

Percept D’Mark (India) (P) Ltd. v. Zaheer Khan

(2006) 4 SCC 227 · Supreme Court of India · 2006

Legal issue. Can a right-of-first-refusal obligation restrain post-term professional endorsements?

Ratio. The Court held the post-term restraint unenforceable under Section 27 and refused to compel performance through an injunction.

Read facts, significance and research notes

Material facts

A sports-management contract imposed a right of first refusal affecting a cricketer’s later endorsements.

Why this case matters

Leading decision on post-termination restraints, celebrity contracts and specific-performance limits.

Relevant provisions

Section 27; Specific Relief Act

Source description

Privy Council judgment, public full-text reproduction. Decided 22 March 2006.

05 / 10

Frustration, force majeure and changed circumstances

Supervening events do not automatically rewrite prices. The contract’s allocation of risk matters first.

Frustration, force majeure and changed circumstancesCASE 19

Satyabrata Ghose v. Mugneeram Bangur & Co.

AIR 1954 SC 44 · Supreme Court of India · 1953

Legal issue. Does wartime requisition frustrate a land development contract?

Ratio. Impossibility in Section 56 is practical, not simply literal. On these facts, the temporary interruption did not frustrate the contract.

Read facts, significance and research notes

Material facts

Government requisitioned land temporarily during wartime, delaying a planned development scheme.

Why this case matters

Explains the statutory doctrine of frustration and the scope of genuine supervening impossibility.

Relevant provisions

Sections 32, 56

Source description

Supreme Court judgment, public full-text reproduction. Decided 16 November 1953.

Frustration, force majeure and changed circumstancesCASE 20

Alopi Parshad & Sons Ltd. v. Union of India

AIR 1960 SC 588 · Supreme Court of India · 1960

Legal issue. Does a dramatic price increase permit rewriting contractual remuneration?

Ratio. Mere commercial hardship or rising costs do not allow a court or arbitrator to replace agreed rates where performance remains possible.

Read facts, significance and research notes

Material facts

Government procurement agents sought additional payment during wartime changes to market conditions.

Why this case matters

Classic authority rejecting hardship alone as frustration or a basis for quantum meruit.

Relevant provisions

Sections 56, 70

Source description

Supreme Court judgment, public full-text reproduction. Decided 20 January 1960.

Frustration, force majeure and changed circumstancesCASE 21

Energy Watchdog v. Central Electricity Regulatory Commission

(2017) 14 SCC 80 · Supreme Court of India · 2017

Legal issue. Do coal-price changes excuse obligations under power-purchase agreements?

Ratio. An agreed force-majeure allocation is construed under Section 32; absent an applicable clause, Section 56 requires more than commercial onerousness.

Read facts, significance and research notes

Material facts

Power generators invoked force majeure after increased Indonesian coal prices affected financial viability.

Why this case matters

Modern leading authority on force majeure, Section 32 and Section 56.

Relevant provisions

Sections 32, 56

Source description

Supreme Court judgment, public full-text reproduction. Decided 11 April 2017.

Frustration, force majeure and changed circumstancesCASE 22

National Agricultural Cooperative Marketing Federation of India v. Alimenta S.A.

AIR 2020 SC 2681 · Supreme Court of India · 2020

Legal issue. Can statutory export restrictions affect enforcement of a commodity supply obligation?

Ratio. The Court considered the contractual prohibition clause, subsequent impossibility and public policy while refusing enforcement of the foreign award on its facts.

Read facts, significance and research notes

Material facts

A supply agreement encountered government restrictions affecting export of contracted goods.

Why this case matters

Shows how statutory restrictions and contingency clauses can affect performance and award enforcement.

Relevant provisions

Sections 32, 56; Arbitration and Conciliation Act

Source description

Supreme Court judgment, public full-text reproduction. Decided 22 April 2020.

06 / 10

Restitution and obligations resembling contracts

Restitution sometimes arises without a valid contract, but each statutory condition still requires proof.

Restitution and obligations resembling contractsCASE 23

Sales Tax Officer v. Kanhaiya Lal Mukundlal Saraf

AIR 1959 SC 135 · Supreme Court of India · 1958

Legal issue. May money paid under a mistake of law be recovered?

Ratio. Section 72 covers money paid by mistake of law as well as fact, subject to applicable legal and procedural restrictions.

Read facts, significance and research notes

Material facts

A trader paid sales tax on transactions subsequently found outside the taxing power.

Why this case matters

Foundation for restitution of mistaken payments.

Relevant provisions

Section 72

Source description

Supreme Court judgment, public full-text reproduction. Decided 23 September 1958.

Restitution and obligations resembling contractsCASE 24

State of West Bengal v. B.K. Mondal & Sons

AIR 1962 SC 779 · Supreme Court of India · 1961

Legal issue. Can Government retain benefits from work without a valid formal contract?

Ratio. Section 70 permits compensation where an act is lawful, not intended to be gratuitous and its benefit is enjoyed, despite no enforceable contract.

Read facts, significance and research notes

Material facts

A contractor performed additional construction which Government used despite deficient formal contracting requirements.

Why this case matters

Leading exposition of non-gratuitous services and unjust enrichment.

Relevant provisions

Section 70

Source description

Supreme Court judgment, public full-text reproduction. Decided 5 December 1961.

Restitution and obligations resembling contractsCASE 25

Mulamchand v. State of Madhya Pradesh

AIR 1968 SC 1218 · Supreme Court of India · 1968

Legal issue. Can restitution arise despite a Government contract failing constitutional formalities?

Ratio. A void governmental contract cannot simply be ratified as a contract; Section 70 relief may nevertheless follow when its separate conditions are met.

Read facts, significance and research notes

Material facts

Forest-produce arrangements lacked prescribed constitutional contracting formalities.

Why this case matters

Separates invalid public contracting from restitution of benefits.

Relevant provisions

Section 70; Constitution Article 299

Source description

Supreme Court judgment, public full-text reproduction. Decided 20 February 1968.

Restitution and obligations resembling contractsCASE 26

Mahabir Kishore v. State of Madhya Pradesh

(1989) 4 SCC 1 · Supreme Court of India · 1989

Legal issue. How does limitation apply to a refund for money paid under legal mistake?

Ratio. The Court applied the law of mistaken payment, unjust enrichment and discovery for determining limitation on the particular record.

Read facts, significance and research notes

Material facts

Contractors sought reimbursement of a Government cess collected without legal authority.

Why this case matters

Links Section 72 restitution with limitation and awareness of legal mistake.

Relevant provisions

Section 72; Limitation Act

Source description

Supreme Court judgment, public full-text reproduction. Decided 31 July 1989.

Restitution and obligations resembling contractsCASE 27

Madhu Kudapa (formerly K. Madhusudhan Rao) v. Lodha Healthy Constructions and Developer (P) Ltd.

2026 INSC 1131 · Supreme Court of India · 2026

Legal issue. To whom should a builder’s refund be directed when a housing loan financed the purchase?

Ratio. The Court assessed unjust enrichment and restitution alongside consumer remedies, and apportioned relief while preserving the lender’s pending rights.

Read facts, significance and research notes

Material facts

A flat buyer sought repayment after the builder failed to deliver possession under a tripartite financing arrangement.

Why this case matters

Recent application of restitutionary principles in consumer and tripartite property contracts.

Relevant provisions

Sections 68–72 (discussed); Consumer Protection Act

Context and later treatment

Consumer-law dispute applying restitution; not a general replacement for Sections 68–72.

Source description

Supreme Court judgment, public full-text reproduction. Decided 15 October 2026.

07 / 10

Contract interpretation, performance and termination

Interpretation starts with the agreed text; remedies depend upon the terms and the nature of performance.

Contract interpretation, performance and terminationCASE 28

Nabha Power Ltd. v. Punjab State Power Corporation Ltd.

(2018) 11 SCC 508 · Supreme Court of India · 2017

Legal issue. When may a court imply a term into a detailed commercial contract?

Ratio. The Court addressed business efficacy and the stringent necessity test for implied terms; mere reasonableness does not justify rewriting a contract.

Read facts, significance and research notes

Material facts

A power-purchase dispute raised a claim about charges not expressly allocated in the written arrangement.

Why this case matters

Leading Indian exposition of implied contractual terms and commercial interpretation.

Relevant provisions

Sections 10, 37

Source description

Supreme Court judgment, public full-text reproduction. Decided 5 October 2017.

Contract interpretation, performance and terminationCASE 29

Indian Oil Corporation Ltd. v. Amritsar Gas Service

(1991) 1 SCC 533 · Supreme Court of India · 1990

Legal issue. What remedy follows wrongful termination of a determinable distribution contract?

Ratio. The Court found that reinstatement contradicted the limits on specific enforcement of a determinable agreement; contractual damages were the appropriate avenue.

Read facts, significance and research notes

Material facts

A petroleum distributorship was terminated and reinstatement was sought through arbitration.

Why this case matters

Important for termination clauses and distinction between damages and specific performance.

Relevant provisions

Section 73; Specific Relief Act

Source description

Supreme Court judgment, public full-text reproduction. Decided 19 November 1990.

08 / 10

Breach, compensation, penalties and forfeiture

Compensation redresses legal injury. Forfeiture and agreed sums require careful classification and assessment.

Breach, compensation, penalties and forfeitureCASE 30

Pannalal Jankidas v. Mohanlal

AIR 1951 SC 144 · Supreme Court of India · 1950

Legal issue. When are consequential losses recoverable from an agent for negligence?

Ratio. The Court examined causation and remoteness when deciding liability for losses flowing from an agent’s failure to insure.

Read facts, significance and research notes

Material facts

A commission agent failed to arrange insurance; goods were destroyed in an explosion.

Why this case matters

Useful in studying Section 73 alongside an agent’s duty of care.

Relevant provisions

Sections 73, 212

Source description

Supreme Court judgment, public full-text reproduction. Decided 21 December 1950.

Breach, compensation, penalties and forfeitureCASE 31

Fateh Chand v. Balkishan Das

AIR 1963 SC 1405 · Supreme Court of India · 1963

Legal issue. Does a forfeiture clause automatically entitle the other party to the full amount?

Ratio. Section 74 authorises reasonable compensation capped by the stipulated amount, rather than automatic enforcement of every penalty.

Read facts, significance and research notes

Material facts

A property sale collapsed and the seller sought to forfeit money paid under the bargain.

Why this case matters

Five-judge authority underpinning modern forfeiture and liquidated-damages law.

Relevant provisions

Section 74

Source description

Supreme Court judgment, public full-text reproduction. Decided 15 January 1963.

Breach, compensation, penalties and forfeitureCASE 32

Maula Bux v. Union of India

AIR 1970 SC 1955 · Supreme Court of India · 1969

Legal issue. When can a security deposit be forfeited without proof of loss?

Ratio. Where loss can be reasonably assessed, proof of loss matters; an agreed sum does not invariably authorise forfeiture in full.

Read facts, significance and research notes

Material facts

A supplier’s performance deposits were forfeited following a Government supply dispute.

Why this case matters

Explains the evidentiary limits of claims under Section 74.

Relevant provisions

Section 74

Source description

Supreme Court judgment, public full-text reproduction. Decided 19 August 1969.

Breach, compensation, penalties and forfeitureCASE 33

Oil & Natural Gas Corporation Ltd. v. Saw Pipes Ltd.

(2003) 5 SCC 705 · Supreme Court of India · 2003

Legal issue. When can pre-estimated delay damages be granted in commercial contracts?

Ratio. Reasonable pre-estimated compensation can be recoverable when the loss is difficult to prove; the Court also addressed the statutory setting-aside standard for awards.

Read facts, significance and research notes

Material facts

A delayed supply dispute led to an arbitral award disallowing contractual liquidated damages.

Why this case matters

Read with Fateh Chand, Kailash Nath and later arbitration-law developments.

Relevant provisions

Sections 73, 74; Arbitration and Conciliation Act

Source description

Supreme Court judgment, public full-text reproduction. Decided 17 April 2003.

Breach, compensation, penalties and forfeitureCASE 34

Kailash Nath Associates v. Delhi Development Authority

(2015) 4 SCC 136 · Supreme Court of India · 2015

Legal issue. Can earnest money be forfeited despite no breach or loss?

Ratio. Section 74 requires legal injury and reasonable compensation. Earnest-money forfeiture under an existing contract is ordinarily subject to its limits; a pre-contract auction may differ.

Read facts, significance and research notes

Material facts

DDA sought to forfeit a bidder’s deposit while the property was later resold at a higher price.

Why this case matters

Comprehensive synthesis of penalty, loss, earnest money and compensatory limits.

Relevant provisions

Section 74

Guidelines and practical application

Assess whether a binding contract was breached. Identify loss or legal injury. Determine whether loss is capable of proof. Keep reasonable compensation within the stipulated ceiling. Distinguish deposits forfeited before any contract was concluded.

Source description

Supreme Court judgment, public full-text reproduction. Decided 9 January 2015.

Breach, compensation, penalties and forfeitureCASE 35

K.R. Suresh v. R. Poornima

2025 INSC 617 · Supreme Court of India · 2025

Legal issue. When does an advance function as forfeitable earnest money, and must refund be expressly claimed?

Ratio. On these facts, the amount functioned as earnest money and forfeiture was upheld. The Court held that refund under Specific Relief Act Section 22(1)(b) must be specifically sought.

Read facts, significance and research notes

Material facts

A purchaser paid Rs.20 lakh under an agreement to sell but failed to complete payment within the contractual period.

Why this case matters

Crucial later treatment: analyse the character of a deposit and the proved circumstances, rather than asserting that every forfeiture attracts Section 74 identically.

Relevant provisions

Section 74; Specific Relief Act Section 22

Guidelines and practical application

Examine contractual language and purpose of deposit. Check purchaser default, the fairness of the clause and actual prejudice. Plead alternative refund under Section 22 of the Specific Relief Act where relief is sought.

Context and later treatment

Specific fact-sensitive discussion of earnest money; compare carefully with Kailash Nath.

Source description

Reported judgment, public full-text reproduction. Decided 2 May 2025.

Breach, compensation, penalties and forfeitureCASE 36

BPL Ltd. v. Morgan Securities and Credits (P) Ltd.

2025 INSC 1380 · Supreme Court of India · 2025

Legal issue. When are agreed default interest and compounding terms enforceable?

Ratio. The Court upheld the agreed commercial interest structure in its contractual context, rejecting the contention that the provisions were necessarily punitive.

Read facts, significance and research notes

Material facts

Companies entered a bill-discounting arrangement with concessionary and normal interest rates and default provisions.

Why this case matters

Recent detailed consideration of Section 74, penal interest, interpretation and arbitral interest.

Relevant provisions

Section 74; Arbitration and Conciliation Act Section 31(7)

Context and later treatment

The case involved a negotiated commercial bill-discounting arrangement; generalisation to consumer loans is unwarranted.

Source description

Supreme Court judgment, public full-text reproduction. Decided 4 December 2025.

Breach, compensation, penalties and forfeitureCASE 37

Saisudhir Energy Ltd. v. NTPC Vidyut Vyapar Nigam Ltd.

2026 INSC 103 · Supreme Court of India · 2026

Legal issue. Can a utility purchaser recover liquidated damages for delayed solar-power commissioning?

Ratio. The Supreme Court restored the Single Judge’s quantified award and rejected the Division Bench’s modification, examining reasonable compensation and the nature of loss.

Read facts, significance and research notes

Material facts

A solar developer commissioned generating capacity later than contractually agreed, triggering delay-damages clauses.

Why this case matters

Significant 2026 decision on Section 74 and public-utility delay losses.

Relevant provisions

Section 74; Arbitration and Conciliation Act

Context and later treatment

The outcome turns on the power-purchase agreement and the reasoning for the quantum awarded.

Source description

Supreme Court judgment, public full-text reproduction. Decided 30 January 2026.

09 / 10

Guarantee, security and suretyship

Suretyship depends upon the promise undertaken, not merely the commercial relationship or label.

Guarantee, security and suretyshipCASE 38

Bank of Bihar Ltd. v. Damodar Prasad

AIR 1969 SC 297 · Supreme Court of India · 1968

Legal issue. Must a creditor exhaust remedies against the borrower before proceeding against the surety?

Ratio. Subject to the guarantee terms, the surety’s liability is co-extensive and immediate; the creditor need not first exhaust remedies against the borrower.

Read facts, significance and research notes

Material facts

A bank enforced a debt against both the principal debtor and guarantor.

Why this case matters

Foundational decision interpreting Section 128.

Relevant provisions

Section 128

Source description

Supreme Court judgment, public full-text reproduction. Decided 8 August 1968.

Guarantee, security and suretyshipCASE 39

Maharashtra State Electricity Board v. Official Liquidator

(1982) 3 SCC 358 · Supreme Court of India · 1982

Legal issue. Does liquidation of the principal obligor automatically extinguish a bank guarantee?

Ratio. The guarantor’s independent obligation was not discharged merely because the principal company had entered liquidation.

Read facts, significance and research notes

Material facts

A company entered liquidation while an electricity board sought payment under a bank guarantee.

Why this case matters

Illustrates the separate force of commercial guarantee obligations.

Relevant provisions

Sections 126, 128, 134

Source description

Supreme Court judgment, public full-text reproduction. Decided 13 October 1982.

Guarantee, security and suretyshipCASE 40

State Bank of India v. Mula Sahakari Sakhar Karkhana Ltd.

(2006) 6 SCC 293 · Supreme Court of India · 2006

Legal issue. How do courts determine whether a bank instrument is a guarantee or an indemnity?

Ratio. The instrument must be interpreted from its actual wording and underlying commercial terms; labels alone do not determine scope.

Read facts, significance and research notes

Material facts

A sugar cooperative sought payment following disputes under a machinery project.

Why this case matters

Useful for distinguishing guarantee, indemnity and conditional bank obligations.

Relevant provisions

Sections 124, 126

Source description

Supreme Court judgment, public full-text reproduction. Decided 6 July 2006.

Guarantee, security and suretyshipCASE 41

UV Asset Reconstruction Co. Ltd. v. Electrosteel Castings Ltd.

2026 INSC 14 · Supreme Court of India · 2026

Legal issue. When is a promoter undertaking a guarantee under Section 126?

Ratio. The Court found that the particular undertaking did not create a contractual guarantee of the borrower’s debt, requiring analysis of its actual promise and parties.

Read facts, significance and research notes

Material facts

A financing agreement involved a corporate promoter’s undertaking to arrange equity support for the borrower.

Why this case matters

Contemporary authority on classification of guarantees, distinct from commitments to infuse or arrange funds.

Relevant provisions

Section 126; Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code

Source description

Supreme Court judgment, public full-text reproduction. Decided 6 January 2026.

10 / 10

Bailment, pledge and possessory obligations

Possession of another’s goods can carry strict duties regarding care, redemption and accountable recovery.

Bailment, pledge and possessory obligationsCASE 42

State of Bombay v. Memon Mahomed Haji Hasam

AIR 1967 SC 1885 · Supreme Court of India · 1967

Legal issue. Can obligations comparable to bailment arise after statutory seizure without a consensual contract?

Ratio. A custodian who must return goods can owe the care expected of a bailee even without a conventional enforceable bailment agreement.

Read facts, significance and research notes

Material facts

Government seized vehicles subsequently required to be returned.

Why this case matters

Explains the duty to preserve goods entrusted or held under law.

Relevant provisions

Sections 148, 151, 152

Source description

Supreme Court judgment, public full-text reproduction. Decided 5 May 1967.

Bailment, pledge and possessory obligationsCASE 43

Lallan Prasad v. Rahmat Ali

AIR 1967 SC 1322 · Supreme Court of India · 1966

Legal issue. May a pledgee recover the debt while refusing to return pledged goods?

Ratio. Section 176 permits suit on the debt and retention of the security, but the pledgee must remain able to return pledged goods upon redemption; double recovery is not permitted.

Read facts, significance and research notes

Material facts

A lender sued on a debt while disputing receipt of the pledged scrap goods.

Why this case matters

Leading exposition of pledgee’s remedies and the pawner’s right of redemption.

Relevant provisions

Sections 172–176

Source description

Supreme Court judgment, public full-text reproduction. Decided 13 December 1966.

Research method and scope

This edition includes selected landmark decisions and relevant Supreme Court judgments up to 16 November 2026. Links lead to publicly accessible judgment reproductions, with one Supreme Court-hosted PDF. They are not all official certified copies.

The compilation distinguishes statutory holdings from facts and modern qualifications. Sections 32, 56, 70, 73, 74, 126 and 128 receive specific attention. The 2025 forfeiture judgment should be compared against Kailash Nath, not read as blanket overruling.

Some classic classroom authorities, including Lalman Shukla v. Gauri Dutt, are omitted because their full original judgments were not independently verified here. This is a curated collection, not a claim to cover every reported judgment or subsequent citation.

Primary statute: The Indian Contract Act, 1872, India Code.

© LawFoyer · Research edition of 16 November 2026lawfoyer.in
Share this :
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
WhatsApp