Jurisprudence & Legal Theory
Previous-Year MCQs
How to use this compilation
Choose a topic, select one answer, and press Check answer. Open Explanation and correct answer when ready. Search, filter by year, and track questions you have checked in your browser.
Research disclosure: Most questions are paraphrased from third-party UGC NET compilations. Their exam labels and answers have been reviewed but not individually matched to NTA question IDs or official keys. They must not be represented as fully authenticated official PYQs. A Delhi Judicial Service question is traceable to an identified 2023 paper. The target of 500 is not met.
Nature and sources of law 24 documented questions
Which jurist described jurisprudence as the science of positive law?
Explanation and correct answer
Answer: A. John Austin
Austin developed the analytical account of positive law as sovereign commands. Do not confuse this formulation with Holland’s definition as the formal science of positive law.
A matching question paired retributive theory, immemorial antiquity, Grundnorm and locus standi with their related concepts. Which pairing is correct?
Explanation and correct answer
Answer: C. Retribution–punishment; antiquity–custom; Grundnorm–Kelsen; locus standi–PIL
Retribution concerns punishment; antiquity supports custom; Kelsen introduced Grundnorm; locus standi concerns standing to initiate proceedings.
Which jurisprudential school studies law as it currently exists by analysing legal rules and concepts?
Explanation and correct answer
Answer: A. Analytical school
Analytical jurisprudence examines positive legal rules, their structure and concepts without first asking what law ought to be.
Which jurist compared the development of law with language changing across communities and eras?
Explanation and correct answer
Answer: C. F. C. von Savigny
Savigny linked law with the historical consciousness of a people, commonly termed Volksgeist.
Who characterised Kelsen’s pure theory of law as an exercise in logic rather than lived experience?
Explanation and correct answer
Answer: D. Harold Laski
Harold Laski criticised the abstract character of pure legal theory. The theory itself belongs to Hans Kelsen, not Savigny.
Who emphasised law emerging from social facts and social pressure, rather than solely from state commands?
Explanation and correct answer
Answer: B. Eugen Ehrlich
Ehrlich’s sociological jurisprudence concentrated on the living law operating within society.
Which school traditionally distinguishes the legislature as lawmaker from the judiciary as law-applier?
Explanation and correct answer
Answer: A. Analytical jurisprudence
Classical analytical jurisprudence emphasises enacted law and institutional separation, although modern accounts recognise judicial law-making.
Who classified sources of law into formal and material sources?
Explanation and correct answer
Answer: D. John Salmond
Salmond distinguished sources conferring legal force from material sources supplying the substance of legal rules.
Who called jurisprudence the lawyer’s examination of legal techniques and ideals using knowledge from outside law?
Explanation and correct answer
Answer: D. Julius Stone
Julius Stone advanced an interdisciplinary approach to jurisprudence, often described as the lawyer’s extraversion.
An older PYQ connected judicial liberum arbitrium in matters of equity and reasonableness with what?
Explanation and correct answer
Answer: B. Reasoned submissions and arguments
The reproduced key selected reasoned submissions and arguments. The historical Latin formulation should be read with its procedural context.
Which combination of requirements for a legally binding custom was selected in the reported examination?
Explanation and correct answer
Answer: D. Statements 1 and 2
Statements 1 and 2 covered antiquity, reasonableness, observance as of right and compatibility with statute law; statement 3 was not selected. Statement numbering follows the source: 1 = reasonableness, antiquity, statutory conformity; 2 = immemorial usage, statutory conformity, usage as of right; 3 = specificity, efficacy, reasonableness.
Which jurist used formal and material concepts while defining jurisprudence?
Explanation and correct answer
Answer: B. T. E. Holland
Holland’s well-known definition is jurisprudence as the formal science of positive law.
Who offered the definition involving knowledge of divine and human matters and the science of right and wrong?
Explanation and correct answer
Answer: D. Ulpian
The Roman jurist Ulpian is associated with the classical definition of jurisprudence.
Which combination was identified as advantages of legislation over precedents: abrogation, advance notice, prospectivity and systematic arrangement?
Explanation and correct answer
Answer: C. All four
Legislation is commonly considered more systematically arranged and capable of prospective change and express repeal than case-by-case precedents.
Which thinker situated legal theory between philosophy and political theory?
Explanation and correct answer
Answer: B. W. Friedmann
Friedmann connected the study of legal institutions and concepts with broader philosophical and political theory.
Who described jurisprudence as studying and systematically arranging general legal principles?
Explanation and correct answer
Answer: C. G. W. Keeton
Keeton used this formulation to describe the systematic study of general legal principles.
Which statement correctly attributes the idea that a person’s only right is to perform their duty?
Explanation and correct answer
Answer: A. It is associated with Léon Duguit
Duguit linked law to social solidarity and criticised subjective individual rights. Pound is associated with social engineering.
Who divided legal sources into binding and persuasive categories?
Explanation and correct answer
Answer: A. G. W. Keeton
The reproduced question attributes this classification to Keeton. Binding sources govern decisions; persuasive sources can guide reasoning.
From which civilisation is the Latin term jurisprudentia derived?
Explanation and correct answer
Answer: B. Roman
Jurisprudentia is Latin and belongs to Roman legal terminology. The phrasing is paraphrased to avoid confusing Latin with Greek.
Which propositions describe legal theory: A defines law, B analyses concepts, C has no practical value, D explains legal-system features?
Explanation and correct answer
Answer: C. A, B and D
Legal theory defines and analyses law and its institutions. The suggestion that it has no practical importance is false.
Which Indian interpretive tradition distinguishes obligatory injunctions from recommendations?
Explanation and correct answer
Answer: B. Mimamsa
Mimamsa developed interpretive principles for classifying Vedic injunctions, including binding and recommendatory statements.
Who described international law as the vanishing point of jurisprudence?
Explanation and correct answer
Answer: C. T. E. Holland
Holland questioned international law’s fit within classical sovereign-command accounts of jurisprudence.
Match four texts with their authors: Some Reflections in Jurisprudence, Elementa Philosophiae, Elements of Jurisprudence, Elementary Principles of Jurisprudence. Which order matches authors Julius Stone, Hobbes, Holland and Keeton?
Explanation and correct answer
Answer: B. Stone–Hobbes–Holland–Keeton
The works are attributed respectively to Julius Stone, Thomas Hobbes, T. E. Holland and G. W. Keeton. The options consolidate the source’s matching codes.
The doctrine of stare decisis concerns which source of law?
Explanation and correct answer
Answer: A. Judicial precedent
Stare decisis means following decisions of courts when a binding principle governs materially similar facts. Article 141 gives binding force to law declared by the Supreme Court.
Schools of jurisprudence 17 documented questions
Match internal morality of law, minimum content of natural law, natural law with changing content and movement from status to contract.
Explanation and correct answer
Answer: B. Fuller, Hart, Stammler, Maine
Fuller proposed inner morality; Hart examined minimum natural-law content; Stammler proposed variable-content natural law; Maine described status-to-contract development.
Who distinguished expository jurisprudence from censorial jurisprudence?
Explanation and correct answer
Answer: C. Jeremy Bentham
Bentham separated explanation of law as it is from criticism of law as it ought to be.
With whom is natural law having variable content particularly associated?
Explanation and correct answer
Answer: B. Rudolf Stammler
Stammler retained the idea of just law while allowing its social content to vary with circumstances.
Match social solidarity, categorical imperative, imperative theory of law and living law with their jurists.
Explanation and correct answer
Answer: C. Duguit, Kant, Austin, Ehrlich
Duguit proposed social solidarity, Kant categorical imperative, Austin imperative theory, and Ehrlich living law.
Match normative order, theory of justice, changing-content natural law and social utilitarianism.
Explanation and correct answer
Answer: C. Kelsen, Rawls, Stammler, Ihering
The corresponding thinkers are Kelsen, Rawls, Stammler and Ihering.
Which response did the reproduced PYQ accept for Austin’s inability to fully accommodate constitutional law, custom and precedent?
Explanation and correct answer
Answer: A. Both assertion and reason are true; reason explains assertion
The assertion criticised the command model; the reason observed that these sources have a different pedigree from legislation. This is a general critique, not a claim that courts cannot enforce custom.
Match The Growth of the Law, Foundations of Jurisprudence, The Nature and Sources of the Law, and Taking Rights Seriously.
Explanation and correct answer
Answer: B. Cardozo, Jerome Hall, Gray, Dworkin
Cardozo authored The Growth of the Law; Jerome Hall wrote Foundations of Jurisprudence; Gray authored The Nature and Sources of the Law; Dworkin wrote Taking Rights Seriously.
Match Bentham, Puchta, Herbert Spencer and Gray with jurisprudential schools.
Explanation and correct answer
Answer: A. Analytical, historical, sociological, realist
The reproduced classification pairs Bentham with analytical, Puchta with historical, Spencer with sociological, and Gray with realist jurisprudence.
Match Volksgeist, social solidarity, dictates of reason and social control to their thinkers.
Explanation and correct answer
Answer: A. Savigny, Duguit, Aquinas, Ihering
Savigny discussed Volksgeist, Duguit solidarity, Aquinas reason in natural law, and Ihering law as social control.
Which propositions were selected as positivist ideas: 1 law as command, 2 conceptual analysis distinct from social history, 3 morality as deduction of decisions, 4 separating law as is from law ought?
Explanation and correct answer
Answer: B. 1, 2 and 4
The source selected propositions 1, 2 and 4. These describe different strands of legal positivism rather than one unified claim of all positivists.
Who argued for a pure theory excluding sociological, metaphysical and moral elements from legal science?
Explanation and correct answer
Answer: C. Hans Kelsen
Kelsen sought to describe law as a normative order without reducing legal validity to morality or sociology.
Which school was linked in the PYQ with law’s continuous change through actual court behaviour?
Explanation and correct answer
Answer: A. Legal realism
Realist thinkers emphasised the operation of courts and legal decision-making in practice. Their claims should not be reduced to change alone.
Arrange Kant, Bentham, Austin, Maine and Kelsen by birth.
Explanation and correct answer
Answer: B. Kant, Bentham, Austin, Maine, Kelsen
Their birth years are 1724, 1748, 1790, 1822 and 1881, respectively.
Which word did Bentham prefer in explaining the imperative conception of law?
Explanation and correct answer
Answer: B. Mandate
The secondary reproduction marks mandate; the question concerns Bentham’s imperative terminology.
How did Jerome Frank describe his own realist orientation?
Explanation and correct answer
Answer: B. Constructive scepticism
Jerome Frank was a leading American legal realist, associated with constructive scepticism about certainty in adjudication.
Choose the historical sequence from classical Greek natural law to Hobbes, Bentham, Austin and Fuller.
Explanation and correct answer
Answer: D. Greeks, Hobbes, Bentham, Austin, Fuller
The sequence follows the dates of the relevant intellectual developments: Greek thought, Hobbes, Bentham, Austin and Fuller.
Which school did the reported paper associate with a universal metaphysical account of historical legal development?
Explanation and correct answer
Answer: B. Metaphysical school
The secondary source selected metaphysical school. This classification depends upon the terminology used in that particular question.
Law and morality 2 documented questions
Which phrase described moral rules in the classic positivist distinction from sovereign commands?
Explanation and correct answer
Answer: B. Persuasive and non-obligatory
The older imperative account distinguishes enforceable sovereign commands from moral persuasion. Modern positivists offer more nuanced accounts.
Assertion: laws are valid only when just. Reason: law aims at justice. Which evaluation did the source select?
Explanation and correct answer
Answer: D. Assertion false, reason true
In positivist analysis, an unjust law may remain legally valid. Securing justice is an aspiration, not an automatic validity condition.
Rights and duties 7 documented questions
Who described common law as essentially judge-made law?
Explanation and correct answer
Answer: D. Salmond
Salmond emphasised the central position of judicial decisions in the common-law tradition.
Which two theories are central to jurisprudential explanations of legal rights?
Explanation and correct answer
Answer: D. Interest and will theories
Will theory links rights to protected autonomy; interest theory links rights to legally protected interests.
Which are Hohfeld’s correlatives for claim, liberty, power and immunity?
Explanation and correct answer
Answer: B. Duty, no-right, liability, disability
In Hohfeld’s analysis, a claim correlates with duty, a privilege/liberty with no-right, a power with liability, and immunity with disability.
Match will theory, concession theory, declaratory theory and command theory to their principal subjects.
Explanation and correct answer
Answer: C. Legal right, legal person, precedent, analytical school
The source pairs will theory with rights, concession theory with personality, declaratory theory with precedent and command theory with analytical jurisprudence. The source’s matching scheme is followed.
Which combination of duties did Austin classify as absolute: indefinite persons, self-regarding duties, sovereign duties, or duties to parents?
Explanation and correct answer
Answer: A. First three only
Austin discussed duties owed to persons indefinitely, self-regarding duties and duties to the sovereign as categories of absolute duties.
Who defined a legal right as an interest protected by law?
Explanation and correct answer
Answer: C. Rudolf von Ihering
Ihering’s interest theory understands legal rights in terms of protected human interests.
Which two propositions fit Ihering: D rights protect interests and E law reconciles conflicting interests?
Explanation and correct answer
Answer: C. D and E only
Ihering’s interest theory emphasises legally protected interests and the social purpose of resolving conflicts.
Legal personality 7 documented questions
The fiction theory is principally used to explain which concept?
Explanation and correct answer
Answer: C. Corporate personality
Fiction theory treats juristic personality as a legal creation distinct from natural human personality.
What alternative name is used for the bracket theory of corporate personality?
Explanation and correct answer
Answer: B. Symbolist theory
The bracket or symbolist theory regards corporate personality as a useful shorthand for the rights of human participants.
Which was the reproduced paper’s answer concerning whether a Hindu joint family is itself a natural or juristic person?
Explanation and correct answer
Answer: D. Neither
An HUF is separately recognised for some purposes, including taxation, but is not generally a juristic person like a corporation. Context matters.
In the ordinary rule of legal personality, when does a natural person cease to exist as a person?
Explanation and correct answer
Answer: D. At death
Death ends natural personality. Certain estates or representatives may still have legal rights and responsibilities.
Which propositions about corporate personality were accepted: A fiction regards humans as persons; B concession requires legal grant; C fiction equals organic theory; D bracket refers to members; E Savigny, Salmond and Dicey support fiction?
Explanation and correct answer
Answer: D. A, B, D and E
The source identifies A, B, D and E. Fiction and organic or real-entity theories are different accounts.
Which is not ordinarily grouped among theories of corporate legal personality?
Explanation and correct answer
Answer: C. Interest theory
Interest theory primarily concerns legal rights; fiction, concession and bracket theories explain corporate personality.
In which case was the Guru Granth Sahib recognised as a juristic person?
Explanation and correct answer
Answer: D. Shiromani Gurdwara Prabandhak Committee v Som Nath Dass
The Supreme Court recognised the Guru Granth Sahib’s juristic personality in Shiromani Gurdwara Prabandhak Committee v Som Nath Dass (2000).
Property, ownership and possession 6 documented questions
When an agent or servant holds something for a principal, what is the principal’s form of possession?
Explanation and correct answer
Answer: C. Mediate possession
Mediate possession exists where possession is held through another person rather than immediately.
Who stated that individuals have property in their persons, including interests in life, liberty and estate?
Explanation and correct answer
Answer: C. John Locke
Locke articulated natural rights to life, liberty and property in his political philosophy.
How did the reproduced paper classify Salmond’s possession in fact?
Explanation and correct answer
Answer: C. Conception
The source selected conception; Salmond differentiated possession as factual control from possession recognised in law.
What limited proprietary interest permits use of another’s land without giving possession?
Explanation and correct answer
Answer: C. Servitude
Servitudes, including easements, permit restricted use or enjoyment without possession of the land.
Who maintained that the subject matter of ownership is ultimately a right?
Explanation and correct answer
Answer: C. Salmond
Salmond analysed ownership as a legal relation involving rights rather than only physical things.
Assertion: an owner in possession may exclude others. Reason: exclusion and recovery against others are part of ownership.
Explanation and correct answer
Answer: A. Both correct; reason explains assertion
The right to exclude and recover possession is ordinarily an incident of ownership, subject to lawful competing interests.
Liability and punishment 10 documented questions
Which Supreme Court decision is most closely connected with public-law compensation for custodial human-rights violations?
Explanation and correct answer
Answer: D. Nilabati Behera v State of Orissa
Nilabati Behera v State of Orissa (1993) established constitutional compensation for custodial death as a public-law remedy.
How many theories of punishment were counted in the reproduced question?
Explanation and correct answer
Answer: D. Five
The source counts deterrent, preventive, reformative, retributive and expiatory theories. Other textbooks may classify these differently.
Which established punishment theory is most closely connected with expiation?
Explanation and correct answer
Answer: C. Retributive
Expiation concerns atonement and is frequently discussed near retributive ideas in traditional classifications.
Which listed approach is not generally treated as a theory of punishment?
Explanation and correct answer
Answer: C. Concession theory
Concession theory concerns recognition of juristic personality, not criminal punishment.
Which punishment approach focuses on the offender’s psychology and improvement?
Explanation and correct answer
Answer: C. Reformative theory
The reformative approach attempts rehabilitation and positive behavioural change.
Who defined liability by reference to the necessary connection between wrongdoing and its remedy?
Explanation and correct answer
Answer: C. Salmond
Salmond viewed liability as linking a legal wrong to the remedy or sanction that follows.
Which statement reverses the usual distinction between civil and criminal consequences?
Explanation and correct answer
Answer: B. Civil liability entails punishment while criminal liability entails damages
Damages or other civil relief generally follow civil liability; penal sanctions characterise criminal liability. Exceptions and overlap exist.
Which maxim expresses the common mens rea condition for criminal liability?
Explanation and correct answer
Answer: D. Actus non facit reum nisi mens sit rea
The maxim states that an act ordinarily does not make one criminally guilty unless accompanied by a guilty mind, subject to statutory exceptions.
Which duties fall among exceptions to specific enforcement in Salmond’s remedial-liability theory: imperfect, impossible, inexpedient?
Explanation and correct answer
Answer: D. All three
Specific performance may be unavailable for imperfect duties or where performance is impossible or inappropriate.
Match jus necessitatis, malice, dolus/culpa, and intention/negligence with the concepts described.
Explanation and correct answer
Answer: A. Necessity; intention/recklessness; two forms of mens rea; alternative bases of penal liability
Jus necessitatis denotes necessity; malice may encompass intention or recklessness; dolus and culpa describe forms of fault; intention and negligence can constitute alternative fault bases.
Justice and global justice 6 documented questions
What concept concerns a fair distribution of benefits and burdens within a community?
Explanation and correct answer
Answer: A. Distributive justice
Distributive justice asks how social advantages and burdens should be allocated fairly.
Match good law and justice, moral value in positive law, variable-content natural law, and a modern Aristotelian natural-law account.
Explanation and correct answer
Answer: C. Morris, Jerome Hall, Stammler, John Finnis
The source pairs these propositions with Morris, Jerome Hall, Stammler and Finnis, respectively.
Match A Theory of Justice, The Idea of Justice, Nicomachean Ethics and An Enquiry Concerning the Principles of Morals with their authors.
Explanation and correct answer
Answer: C. Rawls, Sen, Aristotle, Hume
The authors are John Rawls, Amartya Sen, Aristotle and David Hume.
Who formally appoints the UN High Commissioner for Human Rights, subject to UN procedures?
Explanation and correct answer
Answer: C. Secretary-General
The Secretary-General appoints the High Commissioner with General Assembly approval under the relevant UN arrangements.
Which statements fit global-justice theories: 1 focus on justice among people, 2 treat individuals as important, 3 focus mainly on justice among states, 4 international justice often treats states as central?
Explanation and correct answer
Answer: B. 1, 2 and 4
The source distinguishes global justice centred on persons from international justice centred on states.
Which book by John Rawls appeared in 1971?
Explanation and correct answer
Answer: D. A Theory of Justice
John Rawls published A Theory of Justice in 1971.
Modernism and post-modernism 3 documented questions
Match post-modernism, source of law, authority of precedent and analytical jurisprudence with CLS, Volksgeist, ratio decidendi and Grundnorm.
Explanation and correct answer
Answer: A. CLS, Volksgeist, ratio decidendi, Grundnorm
The reproduced question pairs post-modernism with critical legal studies, Volksgeist with historical sources, ratio decidendi with precedent, and Grundnorm with analytical/normative theory.
Who described post-modernism as a notoriously ambiguous concept?
Explanation and correct answer
Answer: A. Dennis Lloyd
The reproduced examination attributes this description to Lloyd.
Who wrote The Postmodern Condition: A Report on Knowledge?
Explanation and correct answer
Answer: B. Jean-François Lyotard
Lyotard’s 1979 work examines the status of knowledge and critiques overarching legitimating narratives.
Frequently asked questions
Are these all official NTA PYQs?
No. Most questions come from independently published, exam-attributed reproductions. They are linked individually and should be compared with official question papers and keys before high-stakes use.
Why are some older question numbers missing?
Several secondary archives provide the year and subject but omit original printed question numbers or paper series. Missing information has not been invented.
Does the compilation include judiciary papers?
Yes. The Delhi Judicial Service 2023 question on stare decisis links to a published paper reproduction. The Delhi High Court provides the official examination archive.
What remains to reach 500 questions?
Further original-paper extraction and answer-key reconciliation remain necessary. The target has not been achieved by padding the bank with made-up questions.
