Right to Information Act, 2005: Landmark Cases and Judgments
A topic-wise compilation covering access, exemptions, public authorities, examinations, remedies and Information Commissions. Each entry links to the complete decision or order.
How to read this collection
This compilation concentrates on leading Supreme Court decisions. A small group of constitutional right-to-know rulings predates the RTI Act or concerns other statutes; those cases are expressly marked.
Search judgments
Search titles, citations, issues, facts and legal principles. Filters can be combined.
At-a-glance case index
These links jump directly to the full case analyses below.
- Anjali Bhardwaj v. Union of India (2019)
- Association for Democratic Reforms v. Union of India (Electoral Bonds) (2024)
- Bihar Public Service Commission v. Saiyed Hussain Abbas Rizwi (2012)
- Canara Bank v. C.S. Shyam (2018)
- Central Board of Secondary Education v. Aditya Bandopadhyay (2011)
- Central Information Commission v. Delhi Development Authority (2024)
- Central Public Information Officer, Supreme Court of India v. Subhash Chandra Agarwal (2019)
- Chief Information Commissioner v. High Court of Gujarat (2020)
- Chief Information Commissioner v. State of Manipur (2011)
- D.A.V. College Trust and Management Society v. Director of Public Instructions (2019)
- Ferani Hotels Pvt. Ltd. v. State Information Commissioner (2018)
- Girish Ramchandra Deshpande v. Central Information Commissioner (2012)
- Institute of Chartered Accountants of India v. Shaunak H. Satya (2011)
- Kerala Public Service Commission v. State Information Commission (2016)
- Khanapuram Gandaiah v. Administrative Officer (2010)
- Kishan Chand Jain v. Union of India (Hybrid Hearings) (2023)
- Kishan Chand Jain v. Union of India (Proactive Disclosure) (2023)
- Manohar s/o Manikrao Anchule v. State of Maharashtra (2012)
- Public Information Officer and Registrar v. Onkar Dattatray Kalmankar (2025)
- Reserve Bank of India v. Jayantilal N. Mistry (2016)
- State of Uttar Pradesh v. Raj Narain (1975)
- Thalappalam Service Cooperative Bank Ltd. v. State of Kerala (2013)
- Union of India v. Association for Democratic Reforms (2002)
- Union of India v. Namit Sharma (Review) (2013)
- Union Public Service Commission v. Angesh Kumar (2018)
Constitutional foundations of the right to know
Decisions locating public access to information in Article 19(1)(a). These are constitutional companions, not decisions on a statute enacted later.
State of Uttar Pradesh v. Raj Narain
Legal issue: Whether claims of official secrecy could defeat the public interest in obtaining government records.
Read case analysis
Brief material facts
The litigation concerned production of documents in an election dispute involving a former Prime Minister. The State asserted privilege over the documents.
Judgment and binding principle
The Court treated the people’s right to know about public acts as an important feature of responsible government, while recognising that genuine public-interest secrecy may justify withholding particular material. The issue arose under evidence and privilege law, not the later RTI Act.
Subsequent status / limits
Constitutional precursor; pre-dates the RTI Act.
Why it matters
Foundational constitutional vocabulary for open government. Use it as background when analysing sections 3, 8 and 22, not as an interpretation of the 2005 Act.
Full-text source
Full-text judgment mirror
Union of India v. Association for Democratic Reforms
Legal issue: Does Article 19(1)(a) protect an elector’s right to know relevant information about election candidates?
Read case analysis
Brief material facts
A public-interest challenge sought disclosure of candidates’ criminal antecedents, assets, liabilities and education.
Judgment and binding principle
The Supreme Court recognised voters’ right to relevant candidate information as part of freedom of speech and expression. It supported disclosure duties in the electoral process, distinct from the later RTI application procedure.
Subsequent status / limits
Constitutional precursor, applied within electoral law and subsequent statutory developments.
Why it matters
Frequently examined alongside RTI as an example of information enabling democratic participation.
Full-text source
Full-text judgment mirror
Association for Democratic Reforms v. Union of India (Electoral Bonds)
Legal issue: Whether an anonymous political-funding scheme was compatible with voters’ right to information.
Read case analysis
Brief material facts
The validity of the Electoral Bond Scheme and related statutory amendments was questioned on constitutional grounds.
Judgment and binding principle
The Constitution Bench held the scheme constitutionally invalid, including because anonymous political funding impaired voters’ access to information about political contributions. Its holdings arise under constitutional and electoral law, not sections 6–8 of the RTI Act.
Subsequent status / limits
Constitutional judgment; not an RTI Act appeal.
Why it matters
A modern constitutional companion demonstrating the reach of voters’ right to know beyond statutory RTI requests.
Full-text source
Official Supreme Court judgment PDF
Meaning of information and limits of RTI
What an applicant may seek under sections 2(f), 2(j), 6 and 7.
Khanapuram Gandaiah v. Administrative Officer
Legal issue: Can an applicant require a judge or public official to explain why a judicial decision was made?
Read case analysis
Brief material facts
An applicant asked judicial officers to supply reasons behind their adjudicative decisions through RTI queries.
Judgment and binding principle
Information under section 2(f) covers material available in records; the Act does not oblige an authority to generate explanations or answer why it took a particular decision. Reasons found in an existing record remain a different matter.
Subsequent status / limits
The basic distinction between existing records and newly created answers remains important.
Why it matters
Distinguishes requests for recorded information from interrogatories seeking fresh opinions, justifications or explanations.
Full-text source
Full-text judgment mirror
Examinations, recruitment and evaluation
Answer scripts, model answers, marks, panel identities and examination integrity.
Central Board of Secondary Education v. Aditya Bandopadhyay
Legal issue: Are evaluated answer books “information” that an examinee may inspect under the RTI Act?
Read case analysis
Brief material facts
Examinees sought access to their evaluated answer scripts, and the examining body argued that the materials were exempt or held in confidence.
Judgment and binding principle
Evaluated answer books are records covered by section 2(f), and examinees can normally seek inspection or copies. The examining body does not hold the candidates’ answer books in a fiduciary capacity merely through the evaluation process. The Act does not itself create a right to re-evaluation.
Subsequent status / limits
Read with later examination-integrity decisions, notably UPSC v. Angesh Kumar.
Why it matters
Leading authority for exam-script inspection. Protection of evaluators’ identities and valid exemptions must still be considered.
Full-text source
Full-text judgment mirror
Institute of Chartered Accountants of India v. Shaunak H. Satya
Legal issue: Which examination materials must a professional examining body disclose, and when do exemptions apply?
Read case analysis
Brief material facts
An examinee sought answer keys, model answers, instructions and evaluation-related information held by ICAI.
Judgment and binding principle
The Court differentiated information about completed examinations from material whose premature release could harm the examination system. Access to available records remains the starting point, with section 8 exemptions assessed according to the nature and timing of material.
Subsequent status / limits
Must be considered with CBSE and UPSC decisions; exemptions depend on records and facts.
Why it matters
Useful for exam keys, examiner instructions and disclosure of completed-exam records. Avoid claiming that every confidential exam document must be released.
Full-text source
Full-text judgment mirror
Bihar Public Service Commission v. Saiyed Hussain Abbas Rizwi
Legal issue: Must identifying particulars of recruitment interview-board members be disclosed to a candidate?
Read case analysis
Brief material facts
An information request asked the commission for details relating to members of an interview board in a selection exercise.
Judgment and binding principle
The Court recognised the RTI Act’s transparency objectives but held that certain identifying information about interviewers could attract section 8(1)(g), where disclosure presents risks to safety or exposure to intimidation. The exemption requires attention to the requested material and its consequences.
Subsequent status / limits
The section 8(1)(g) protection remains a separate exemption from the amended personal-information clause.
Why it matters
Distinguishes disclosure of relevant evaluation records from disclosure of identities that may endanger or expose interviewers.
Full-text source
Full-text judgment mirror
Kerala Public Service Commission v. State Information Commission
Legal issue: Can examinees obtain assessed answer papers and the names of persons who evaluated them?
Read case analysis
Brief material facts
A State Public Service Commission resisted disclosure of exam materials and evaluator details requested by candidates.
Judgment and binding principle
The Supreme Court allowed access to answer sheets within the RTI framework but protected evaluators’ identities. The interest in examination transparency does not automatically override legitimate confidentiality and safety concerns about examiners.
Subsequent status / limits
Read alongside CBSE v. Aditya Bandopadhyay and section 8(1)(g).
Why it matters
A frequently tested distinction: disclosure of answer scripts does not necessarily entail disclosure of evaluator identities.
Full-text source
Full-text judgment mirror
Union Public Service Commission v. Angesh Kumar
Legal issue: Do the principles concerning answer scripts require unrestricted disclosure of material used in competitive preliminary examinations?
Read case analysis
Brief material facts
Candidates sought examination-related material from UPSC, with claims about scaling, evaluation methods and examination confidentiality.
Judgment and binding principle
The Court declined to apply the CBSE rule mechanically. The requested material and likely effects on examination integrity, administration and competing public interests had to be assessed in the particular context.
Subsequent status / limits
Fact-sensitive restriction; not a blanket exclusion of all UPSC information.
Why it matters
Prevents over-reading Aditya Bandopadhyay as granting an unrestricted right to every exam-related document or evaluation method.
Full-text source
Full-text judgment mirror
Public Information Officer and Registrar v. Onkar Dattatray Kalmankar
Legal issue: Was disclosure of other candidates’ marks justified in the public interest under the then-applicable section 8(1)(j)?
Read case analysis
Brief material facts
A recruiting authority challenged a Bombay High Court direction to provide other candidates’ examination marks.
Judgment and binding principle
The Supreme Court dismissed the special leave petition. Its short speaking order agreed that disclosure of the marks, although personal information, was necessary in the public interest to maintain transparency in the recruitment process.
Subsequent status / limits
Decided before the 13 November 2025 substitution of section 8(1)(j); reassess under current text.
Why it matters
A significant 2025 order for recruitment transparency, but it is a short SLP disposal rather than an extensive review of every privacy exemption.
Full-text source
Official Supreme Court complete order PDF
Public authorities and substantially financed bodies
Who falls within section 2(h), including aided institutions and cooperatives.
Thalappalam Service Cooperative Bank Ltd. v. State of Kerala
Legal issue: Does statutory registration and supervision make every cooperative society a “public authority” under section 2(h)?
Read case analysis
Brief material facts
Cooperative banks and societies challenged attempts to classify them as public authorities because they were regulated by the Registrar.
Judgment and binding principle
Mere regulatory supervision or statutory control does not by itself prove substantial ownership, control or finance by government. The statutory tests require evidence of the actual relationship. Information held or legally accessible by the regulator may be a distinct question.
Subsequent status / limits
Apply the precise ownership, control and substantial-financing evidence for each institution.
Why it matters
The leading section 2(h) decision for societies, cooperatives and entities regulated by statutory authorities.
Full-text source
Full-text judgment mirror
D.A.V. College Trust and Management Society v. Director of Public Instructions
Legal issue: When does public financial assistance bring a privately managed educational institution within section 2(h)?
Read case analysis
Brief material facts
The case concerned information requests involving educational institutions receiving financial support from government.
Judgment and binding principle
The Court explained that “substantially financed” is a contextual standard, not necessarily a rigid majority-of-budget calculation. Direct or indirect government financial support must be evaluated for its real significance to the body.
Subsequent status / limits
Complementary to Thalappalam; substantial financing and regulatory control are separate routes.
Why it matters
Essential for aided schools, private managements, trusts and NGOs receiving material state support.
Full-text source
Full-text judgment mirror
Privacy, fiduciary duties and commercial information
The limits of sections 8 and 10, balancing access and protected interests.
Girish Ramchandra Deshpande v. Central Information Commissioner
Legal issue: Can another person demand an employee’s service records, disciplinary papers and income-tax returns under RTI?
Read case analysis
Brief material facts
The applicant requested information concerning disciplinary action, assets, service-related issues and tax materials relating to an employee.
Judgment and binding principle
Applying the former section 8(1)(j), the Court treated much of the requested material as personal information, subject to the then-statutory public-interest threshold. Mere curiosity was insufficient to justify disclosure.
Subsequent status / limits
Pre-2025 section 8(1)(j) wording; do not reproduce the former legal test as the current statutory text.
Why it matters
A prominent privacy precedent. Its statutory analysis must be separated from the clause substituted in November 2025.
Full-text source
Official Supreme Court judgment PDF
Reserve Bank of India v. Jayantilal N. Mistry
Legal issue: Could RBI withhold inspection reports and regulatory information under blanket claims of fiduciary confidence?
Read case analysis
Brief material facts
RTI requests sought information concerning RBI inspections, oversight and regulatory treatment of financial institutions.
Judgment and binding principle
The Court rejected blanket reliance on fiduciary or commercial-confidence claims to conceal regulatory information. RBI’s role as financial regulator involved duties toward the public; exemptions require justified application, not generalised secrecy.
Subsequent status / limits
No proposition that all bank customer data or all confidential regulatory materials must invariably be disclosed.
Why it matters
Leading authority for the transparency of financial regulators, subject to precise legal exemptions and later case-specific confidentiality questions.
Full-text source
Full-text judgment mirror
Canara Bank v. C.S. Shyam
Legal issue: Are detailed particulars of a bank’s individual employees’ transfers, postings and service histories public information?
Read case analysis
Brief material facts
An applicant requested personal and service-related information about numerous bank employees.
Judgment and binding principle
Under the earlier section 8(1)(j), the Court found the employee-specific information protected in the circumstances, with no sufficient public-interest justification established. Disclosure cannot be assumed merely because an employer is a public authority.
Subsequent status / limits
Pre-2025 section 8(1)(j) wording; inspect the current clause and section 8(2) separately.
Why it matters
Often contrasted with disclosures concerning institutional accountability. The decision used the former statutory privacy clause.
Full-text source
Full-text judgment mirror
Central Public Information Officer, Supreme Court of India v. Subhash Chandra Agarwal
Legal issue: Does the Chief Justice of India’s office fall within RTI, and how are transparency, judicial independence and privacy reconciled?
Read case analysis
Brief material facts
The appeals concerned access to information connected with the Chief Justice’s office, including declarations and judicial-administration records.
Judgment and binding principle
The Constitution Bench affirmed that the office of the CJI falls within the public authority of the Supreme Court; it rejected categorical immunity. The opinions carefully balance transparency against privacy, confidentiality and judicial independence. Disclosure depends on the actual record and applicable exemptions.
Subsequent status / limits
Delivered under pre-2025 section 8(1)(j); constitutional principles and remaining statutory provisions require separate analysis.
Why it matters
Core Constitution Bench RTI precedent. Treat the majority judgment and separate opinions carefully; it does not mandate automatic release of every judicial record.
Full-text source
Official Supreme Court judgment PDF
Records concerning public administration
Records held by public authorities and safeguards against blanket denials.
Ferani Hotels Pvt. Ltd. v. State Information Commissioner
Legal issue: Can approved building plans and development records held by public authorities be withheld on broad confidentiality claims?
Read case analysis
Brief material facts
The dispute concerned disclosure of building-related plans and information submitted to authorities in connection with a real-estate project.
Judgment and binding principle
The Court rejected a blanket refusal to disclose records concerning a regulated construction project and examined the public interest in transparency about approvals and development. Its relief responded to the statutory and factual setting.
Subsequent status / limits
Case-specific directions should not be converted into an unconditional rule for every private plan.
Why it matters
Useful for municipal and development authority records, although proprietary or safety objections must still be tested on their own facts.
Full-text source
Full-text judgment mirror
Complaints, appeals, penalties and judicial records
The jurisdiction of Information Commissions and procedural restrictions.
Chief Information Commissioner v. State of Manipur
Legal issue: May an Information Commission order disclosure while exercising only its complaint jurisdiction under section 18?
Read case analysis
Brief material facts
A dispute over the route used to approach the Information Commission raised the distinction between complaints and appeals.
Judgment and binding principle
Section 18 empowers the Commission to receive and inquire into complaints. An order requiring access to information ordinarily belongs to the appellate remedy under section 19. The two statutory remedies have distinct functions.
Subsequent status / limits
Follow statutory appeal time limits and distinctions; complaint jurisdiction cannot substitute automatically for section 19.
Why it matters
Central procedural authority for selecting the correct RTI remedy; especially relevant to examination and administrative case questions.
Full-text source
Full-text judgment mirror
Manohar s/o Manikrao Anchule v. State of Maharashtra
Legal issue: What procedural fairness governs action against a Public Information Officer under section 20?
Read case analysis
Brief material facts
The litigation concerned the imposition of sanctions or consequences for alleged non-compliance with RTI obligations.
Judgment and binding principle
The Court emphasised that penalties and recommendations for disciplinary action require attention to the statutory conditions, including an opportunity of hearing. Action under section 20 is not automatic merely because an applicant did not receive information.
Subsequent status / limits
Ensure section 20(1) monetary penalty and section 20(2) disciplinary recommendation are analysed separately.
Why it matters
Useful for distinguishing penalties for unreasonable non-disclosure from disputes about entitlement to a record.
Full-text source
Full-text judgment mirror
Chief Information Commissioner v. High Court of Gujarat
Legal issue: Can an applicant bypass High Court procedural rules for certified judicial copies through a general RTI request?
Read case analysis
Brief material facts
The dispute involved requests for certified copies of High Court case records, ordinarily governed by the court’s rules.
Judgment and binding principle
The Supreme Court recognised that the applicable High Court rules provide a specific process for obtaining certified judicial records. Properly framed judicial-record rules may govern that request, without treating the RTI Act as a blanket substitute for the established procedure.
Subsequent status / limits
Do not generalise this to an absolute exemption for the judiciary or for every type of information held by a High Court.
Why it matters
Examines the boundary between access to court-file copies and access to administrative information held by courts.
Full-text source
Full-text judgment mirror
Information Commission independence and appointments
Qualifications, appointments, administrative powers and internal functioning.
Union of India v. Namit Sharma (Review)
Legal issue: Must Information Commissioners necessarily have judicial qualifications and sit alongside judicial members?
Read case analysis
Brief material facts
The Union sought review of an earlier judgment that had imposed extensive judicial-member requirements for Information Commissions.
Judgment and binding principle
The Supreme Court reviewed the earlier directions and set aside requirements that went beyond the statutory appointment model. Qualifications and selection must follow sections 12 and 15 rather than an imposed judicial-membership scheme.
Subsequent status / limits
Supersedes the inconsistent directions in the original Namit Sharma judgment.
Why it matters
Critical case on subsequent treatment: citing the 2012 Namit Sharma directions without the 2013 review is misleading.
Full-text source
Full-text judgment mirror
Anjali Bhardwaj v. Union of India
Legal issue: What steps are required to address prolonged vacancies and opaque appointments to the CIC and SICs?
Read case analysis
Brief material facts
A public-interest petition described vacancies, delays and administrative obstacles affecting the Information Commissions.
Judgment and binding principle
The Court issued directions about initiating and completing appointments promptly, advertising vacancies and maintaining transparency in selection. It reaffirmed the need for functioning commissions to make RTI remedies effective.
Directions or specific guidelines
The judgment called for a transparent, time-bound appointment process and publication of relevant selection particulars, within the directions specifically given to governments.
Subsequent status / limits
Follow the actual directions and later statutory changes when applying appointment rules.
Why it matters
Leading practical precedent on institutional vacancy management, independence and access to appeals.
Full-text source
Full-text judgment mirror
Central Information Commission v. Delhi Development Authority
Legal issue: Does the Chief Information Commissioner have the authority to constitute benches and regulate internal Commission administration?
Read case analysis
Brief material facts
A Delhi High Court judgment had invalidated Central Information Commission management regulations, including bench arrangements.
Judgment and binding principle
The Supreme Court held that section 12(4) carries sufficient superintendence and management power for constituting benches and framing internal management regulations. It set aside the contrary High Court reading.
Subsequent status / limits
Power concerns internal management under section 12(4), not unlimited external legislative rule-making.
Why it matters
Important recent precedent on the administrative autonomy of an Information Commission.
Full-text source
Official Supreme Court judgment PDF
Proactive disclosure and access to proceedings
Practical directions strengthening sections 4, 12, 15, 19 and 25.
Kishan Chand Jain v. Union of India (Proactive Disclosure)
Legal issue: What must Information Commissions do to improve compliance with the proactive-publication duties of section 4?
Read case analysis
Brief material facts
The petition focused on weak implementation of statutory duties requiring public authorities to publish specified information without waiting for requests.
Judgment and binding principle
The Supreme Court stressed the supervisory and recommendatory role of Information Commissions, including under section 25, in encouraging section 4 compliance. The statutory proactive-disclosure duty is distinct from individual RTI applications.
Directions or specific guidelines
The judgment directed information authorities to strengthen implementation and monitoring of proactive disclosure in the terms specified in its operative directions.
Subsequent status / limits
Separate Supreme Court decision from the October 2023 Kishan Chand Jain judgment on hybrid hearings.
Why it matters
Essential for section 4 and section 25 questions, audits, online publication and reducing avoidable RTI applications.
Full-text source
Full-text judgment mirror
Kishan Chand Jain v. Union of India (Hybrid Hearings)
Legal issue: Should Information Commissions provide electronic filing and hybrid participation for complaints and appeals?
Read case analysis
Brief material facts
The petition sought practical digital access to Information Commissions, particularly for persons unable to attend in person.
Judgment and binding principle
The Supreme Court issued operational directions for facilities including hybrid-mode hearings and online mechanisms to file complaints and appeals. The purpose was to make statutory information remedies accessible across locations.
Directions or specific guidelines
Directions covered hybrid hearings, digital filing and facilitating electronic service/participation, as set out in the judgment.
Subsequent status / limits
A distinct October 2023 petition and holding; do not merge with the August 2023 proactive-disclosure case.
Why it matters
Leading procedural directions for applicants, PIOs and Commissions seeking remote participation.
Full-text source
Official Supreme Court judgment PDF
No case matches these filters. Try another search or clear your selection.
Research verification and limits
Checked through 16 November 2026. The main reference points are full Supreme Court judgment PDFs, full-text judgment mirrors and the current India Code text. Where the link opens a third-party mirror rather than the judiciary website, the case entry identifies it. An order dismissing an SLP is specifically differentiated from a detailed judgment.
This is a selected collection of 25 consequential decisions and orders, not every RTI judgment. It emphasises doctrinal importance. Reported citations and short descriptors should be checked against the original decision before filing. Statutory interpretation may have changed after the 2025 privacy-clause amendment. Any later overruling or refinement not identified here remains a research limitation.
For the primary statute consult the India Code RTI Act. For independent language assistance, use the external Google Translate Websites service below.