TPA, 1882 | Landmark Cases | LawFoyer

Transfer of Property Act, 1882: Landmark Supreme Court Cases | LawFoyer
LawFoyer
LawFoyer | Landmark Case-Law Library

Transfer of Property Act, 1882: Landmark Judgments and Case Analysis

A topic-wise Supreme Court case compilation covering transfer restrictions, sale and registration, lis pendens, part performance, mortgages, leases, gifts and assignments. Each analysis links to the full decision.

38 landmark decisions8 doctrinal topicsResearch checked: 16 November 2026

Find a landmark decision

Search by title, citation, doctrine, facts or holding. Combine filters and change the sorting order.

For translated text, the external Google Translate Websites service requires a publicly hosted page. The local HTML file cannot be submitted as a website URL.

Case index at a glance

  1. Sridhar v. N. Revanna (2020)
  2. Shehammal v. Hasan Khani Rawther (2011)
  3. The Jumma Masjid, Mercara v. Kodimaniandra Deviah (1962)
  4. Hardev Singh v. Gurmail Singh (2007)
  5. Duni Chand v. Vikram Singh (2024)
  6. Kammana Sambamurthy v. Kalipatnapu Atchutamma (2010)
  7. Narandas Karsondas v. S.A. Kamtam (1977)
  8. Suraj Lamp & Industries (P) Ltd. v. State of Haryana (2011)
  9. S. Kaladevi v. V.R. Somasundaram (2010)
  10. Nagubai Ammal v. B. Shama Rao (1956)
  11. Jayaram Mudaliar v. Ayyaswami (1972)
  12. A. Nawab John v. V.N. Subramaniyam (2012)
  13. Thomson Press (India) Ltd. v. Nanak Builders & Investors (P) Ltd. (2013)
  14. Chander Bhan v. Mukhtiar Singh (2024)
  15. H. Anjanappa v. A. Prabhakar (2025)
  16. Celir LLP v. Sumati Prasad Bafna (2024)
  17. Alka Shrirang Chavan v. Hemchandra Rajaram Bhonsale (2026)
  18. Nathulal v. Phoolchand (1969)
  19. Shrimant Shamrao Suryavanshi v. Pralhad Bhairoba Suryavanshi (2002)
  20. Rambhau Namdeo Gajre v. Narayan Bapuji Dhotra (2004)
  21. Ameer Minhaj v. Dierdre Elizabeth (Wright) Issar (2018)
  22. Seth Ganga Dhar v. Shankar Lal (1958)
  23. Pomal Kanji Govindji v. Vrajlal Karsandas Purohit (1988)
  24. Achaldas Durgaji Oswal v. Ramvilas Gangabisan Heda (2003)
  25. Singh Ram v. Sheo Ram (2014)
  26. Bhawanji Lakhamshi v. Himatlal Jamnadas Dani (1971)
  27. R.V. Bhupal Prasad v. State of Andhra Pradesh (1995)
  28. Anthony v. K.C. Ittoop & Sons (2000)
  29. State of U.P. v. Lalji Tandon (2003)
  30. K.B. Saha & Sons (P) Ltd. v. Development Consultant Ltd. (2008)
  31. Nopany Investments (P) Ltd. v. Santokh Singh (HUF) (2007)
  32. Park Street Properties (P) Ltd. v. Dipak Kumar Singh (2016)
  33. K. Balakrishnan v. K. Kamalam (2003)
  34. Asokan v. Lakshmikutty (2007)
  35. Hafeeza Bibi v. Shaikh Farid (2011)
  36. Renikuntla Rajamma v. K. Sarwanamma (2014)
  37. N.P. Saseendran v. N.P. Ponnamma (2025)
  38. ICICI Bank Ltd. v. Official Liquidator of APS Star Industries Ltd. (2010)

Core transfers, restraints and title

Sections 5, 6, 8, 10, 13, 41, 43 and 44. Transferability, future interests, title defects and equitable exceptions.

Core transfers, restraints and title

Sridhar v. N. Revanna (2020)

AIR 2020 SC 824 · Supreme Court of India

Legal issue raised: Whether an absolute prohibition on alienation in a gift deed survives Section 10; whether an unborn-beneficiary rule applied.

Read complete case analysis

Brief material facts

A grandfather gifted property to his minor grandson in 1957, but the deed forbade alienation. The grandson later sold it, prompting his children to challenge the sales.

Judgment and binding principle

The Court treated the absolute restraint on the donee’s power to alienate as void under Section 10. The transfer was to a living grandson, so mentioning possible future brothers in conditions did not convert it into a Section 13 transfer to an unborn person.

Directions or guidelines

No separate generally applicable directions are identified in this case summary. The legal principle above is a statement of the holding, not a court-issued checklist.

Why this precedent matters

A leading distinction between the validity of the original transfer and invalid conditions restricting a transferee’s ownership. The appeal challenging the sales was dismissed.

Qualification and subsequent treatment

The Court distinguished an actual transfer for an unborn person from a reference to future-born persons in a condition.

Judgment source

Supreme Court of India judgment, complete text on Indian Kanoon (unofficial mirror). Open complete decision. No unverified paragraph or bench details are supplied.

Core transfers, restraints and title

Shehammal v. Hasan Khani Rawther (2011)

(2011) 9 SCC 223 · Supreme Court of India

Legal issue raised: How Section 6(a) applies to a prospective heir’s surrender of an expected inheritance and whether estoppel may arise.

Read complete case analysis

Brief material facts

Children executed separate relinquishment deeds while their Muslim father was alive, accepting benefits in connection with potential future shares. The dispute arose after his death.

Judgment and binding principle

A mere chance of succession is not transferable. Nevertheless, on the proved circumstances, an expectant heir who received consideration and induced reliance could be estopped from asserting an inconsistent entitlement after succession opened.

Directions or guidelines

No separate generally applicable directions are identified in this case summary. The legal principle above is a statement of the holding, not a court-issued checklist.

Why this precedent matters

Use the case to separate the statutory bar on transferring spes successionis from an evidence-based estoppel arising from conduct. Do not treat every pre-death relinquishment as valid.

Qualification and subsequent treatment

Application of estoppel depends on the proven transaction and conduct, not a free-standing exception allowing sale of future inheritance.

Judgment source

Supreme Court of India judgment, complete text on Indian Kanoon (unofficial mirror). Open complete decision. No unverified paragraph or bench details are supplied.

Core transfers, restraints and title

The Jumma Masjid, Mercara v. Kodimaniandra Deviah (1962)

AIR 1962 SC 847; 1962 Supp (2) SCR 554 · Supreme Court of India

Legal issue raised: Whether Section 43 can feed a later-acquired title into a transfer made by someone falsely representing an existing interest.

Read complete case analysis

Brief material facts

Reversioners conveyed property as if it belonged to them, although their position before the succession opened involved only an expectancy.

Judgment and binding principle

The Supreme Court distinguished a straightforward transfer of a mere expectancy under Section 6(a) from a transfer for consideration made on a representation of present title. In the latter setting, Section 43 may apply when title is later acquired, at the transferee’s option.

Directions or guidelines

No separate generally applicable directions are identified in this case summary. The legal principle above is a statement of the holding, not a court-issued checklist.

Why this precedent matters

Foundational authority on feeding the grant by estoppel. Read Section 43 alongside, not in disregard of, Section 6(a).

Judgment source

Supreme Court of India judgment, complete text on Indian Kanoon (unofficial mirror). Open complete decision. No unverified paragraph or bench details are supplied.

Core transfers, restraints and title

Hardev Singh v. Gurmail Singh (2007)

(2007) 2 SCC 404 · Supreme Court of India

Legal issue raised: When the doctrine of feeding the grant by estoppel operates under Section 43.

Read complete case analysis

Brief material facts

The dispute concerned sale of land while a family title controversy remained pending and a later attempt to contest the purchaser’s claim.

Judgment and binding principle

The Court analysed Section 43 as an equitable rule founded on the transferor’s representation of title and the later acquisition of an interest. It rejected the appeal on the facts, including the absence of proof of the asserted will.

Directions or guidelines

No separate generally applicable directions are identified in this case summary. The legal principle above is a statement of the holding, not a court-issued checklist.

Why this precedent matters

Important for the elements and personal reach of Section 43. Do not assume a later acquirer automatically gains title without the statutory preconditions.

Judgment source

Supreme Court of India judgment, complete text on Indian Kanoon (unofficial mirror). Open complete decision. No unverified paragraph or bench details are supplied.

Core transfers, restraints and title

Duni Chand v. Vikram Singh (2024)

2024 INSC 516 · Supreme Court of India

Legal issue raised: Can purchasers claiming protection under Section 41 succeed without proving consent, enquiry and good faith?

Read complete case analysis

Brief material facts

A person relied on a disputed later will to transfer land, although an earlier will was upheld as genuine. Purchasers claimed to be protected as bona fide buyers.

Judgment and binding principle

Section 41 required evidence that the ostensible ownership existed with the interested person’s consent, express or implied, and that the buyers took reasonable care and acted in good faith. Those facts were neither pleaded nor proved. The buyers’ protection was rejected.

Directions or guidelines

No separate generally applicable directions are identified in this case summary. The legal principle above is a statement of the holding, not a court-issued checklist.

Why this precedent matters

A recent direct ruling on pleading and proving the ostensible-owner exception. The first appeal was allowed; the appeal supporting the later will was dismissed.

Judgment source

Supreme Court of India, official judgment PDF. Open complete decision. No unverified paragraph or bench details are supplied.

Core transfers, restraints and title

Kammana Sambamurthy v. Kalipatnapu Atchutamma (2010)

AIR 2011 SC 103 · Supreme Court of India

Legal issue raised: Whether a co-owner’s agreement to sell the whole property binds another co-owner and attracts Section 41.

Read complete case analysis

Brief material facts

A husband agreed to sell an entire property, although his wife held an undivided half-share. She had neither executed the contract nor authorised him.

Judgment and binding principle

The wife’s share could not be bound without authority or a proven Section 41 case. The agreement was enforceable against the husband in respect of his own share, not the wife’s.

Directions or guidelines

No separate generally applicable directions are identified in this case summary. The legal principle above is a statement of the holding, not a court-issued checklist.

Why this precedent matters

Useful for Sections 41 and 44 and for partial enforcement against a contracting co-owner; no automatic authority arises from marriage.

Judgment source

Supreme Court of India judgment, complete text on Indian Kanoon (unofficial mirror). Open complete decision. No unverified paragraph or bench details are supplied.

Sales and registration

Sections 54 and 55, alongside the Registration Act, 1908. Distinguishing conveyances from agreements and evidentiary use.

Sales and registration

Narandas Karsondas v. S.A. Kamtam (1977)

(1977) 3 SCC 247 · Supreme Court of India

Legal issue raised: Whether an agreement or auction under a mortgagee’s power of sale transfers ownership and ends the mortgagor’s equity of redemption.

Read complete case analysis

Brief material facts

A housing-society mortgage led to an attempted sale through the mortgagee’s power. The mortgagor disputed that its right of redemption had ended.

Judgment and binding principle

An agreement to sell does not itself create any interest in land under Section 54. The right of redemption is not extinguished merely by a contract or auction arrangement; a legally effective transfer or other recognised extinguishing event is required.

Directions or guidelines

No separate generally applicable directions are identified in this case summary. The legal principle above is a statement of the holding, not a court-issued checklist.

Why this precedent matters

A combined leading authority on sale, conveyancing and Section 60 redemption. The Supreme Court dismissed the appeal.

Judgment source

Supreme Court of India judgment, complete text on Indian Kanoon (unofficial mirror). Open complete decision. No unverified paragraph or bench details are supplied.

Sales and registration

Suraj Lamp & Industries (P) Ltd. v. State of Haryana (2011)

(2012) 1 SCC 656 · Supreme Court of India

Legal issue raised: Whether an agreement to sell, general power of attorney and will arrangement amounts to a completed sale of immovable property.

Read complete case analysis

Brief material facts

The Court examined prevalent SA/GPA/Will arrangements used as substitutes for registered conveyances.

Judgment and binding principle

Instruments such as agreements to sell and powers of attorney do not by themselves convey ownership. Where the law requires a registered conveyance, this substitute route is not a valid mode of sale. Genuine powers of attorney and other legally permissible transactions remain unaffected.

Directions or guidelines

No separate generally applicable directions are identified in this case summary. The legal principle above is a statement of the holding, not a court-issued checklist.

Why this precedent matters

Central authority for property title due diligence. Its holding must not be misread as invalidating every lawful agency arrangement or genuine agreement.

Judgment source

Supreme Court of India judgment, complete text on Indian Kanoon (unofficial mirror). Open complete decision. No unverified paragraph or bench details are supplied.

Sales and registration

S. Kaladevi v. V.R. Somasundaram (2010)

(2010) 5 SCC 401 · Supreme Court of India

Legal issue raised: Can an unregistered sale deed be received as evidence in a suit seeking specific performance?

Read complete case analysis

Brief material facts

An unregistered conveyance was tendered in a contractual enforcement dispute. The lower courts had refused to admit it.

Judgment and binding principle

The proviso to Section 49 of the Registration Act permits use of an unregistered instrument as evidence of a contract in a suit for specific performance, subject to applicable stamping rules and the stated evidentiary purpose. It does not transfer legal title.

Directions or guidelines

No separate generally applicable directions are identified in this case summary. The legal principle above is a statement of the holding, not a court-issued checklist.

Why this precedent matters

Teaches the distinction between proof of contract and proof of completed ownership. The appeal was allowed.

Judgment source

Supreme Court of India judgment, complete text on Indian Kanoon (unofficial mirror). Open complete decision. No unverified paragraph or bench details are supplied.

Lis pendens and transfers during litigation

Section 52. Third-party purchases during pending suits and the limits of subsequent purchasers’ rights.

Lis pendens and transfers during litigation

Nagubai Ammal v. B. Shama Rao (1956)

AIR 1956 SC 593 · Supreme Court of India

Legal issue raised: Whether a transfer during litigation is void outright or subservient to the eventual decree.

Read complete case analysis

Brief material facts

Competing rights traced to sales and an earlier pending suit involving a charge on property.

Judgment and binding principle

Section 52 does not nullify every transfer between vendor and purchaser. Instead, a pendente lite transferee takes subject to the rights eventually determined in the pending proceedings.

Directions or guidelines

No separate generally applicable directions are identified in this case summary. The legal principle above is a statement of the holding, not a court-issued checklist.

Why this precedent matters

A foundational interpretation of lis pendens and its practical effect on intervening purchasers.

Judgment source

Supreme Court of India judgment, complete text on Indian Kanoon (unofficial mirror). Open complete decision. No unverified paragraph or bench details are supplied.

Lis pendens and transfers during litigation

Jayaram Mudaliar v. Ayyaswami (1972)

(1972) 2 SCC 200 · Supreme Court of India

Legal issue raised: How lis pendens applies to transactions during a partition suit and why notice is not its foundation.

Read complete case analysis

Brief material facts

Purchases of disputed land were made after the presentation of a partition proceeding, including in a public sale context.

Judgment and binding principle

The Court explained the public-policy basis of Section 52: pending litigation should not be defeated by successive alienations. Application turns on the suit, the property interest and the form of transfer, rather than the purchaser’s claimed lack of notice.

Directions or guidelines

No separate generally applicable directions are identified in this case summary. The legal principle above is a statement of the holding, not a court-issued checklist.

Why this precedent matters

A standard case for the rationale and reach of Section 52. Distinct statutory sale contexts still require separate analysis.

Judgment source

Supreme Court of India judgment, complete text on Indian Kanoon (unofficial mirror). Open complete decision. No unverified paragraph or bench details are supplied.

Lis pendens and transfers during litigation

A. Nawab John v. V.N. Subramaniyam (2012)

(2012) 7 SCC 738 · Supreme Court of India

Legal issue raised: What rights a subsequent buyer has under Section 52 and whether impleadment automatically follows.

Read complete case analysis

Brief material facts

A subsequent purchaser sought participation in litigation concerning the same property and a specific-performance claim.

Judgment and binding principle

A transfer during the suit remains subject to its outcome. The Court explained that a pendente lite transferee can seek impleadment, but procedural participation does not immunise a transfer from the binding effect of Section 52.

Directions or guidelines

No separate generally applicable directions are identified in this case summary. The legal principle above is a statement of the holding, not a court-issued checklist.

Why this precedent matters

Useful alongside Order XXII Rule 10 CPC. The ultimate appeal also turned on deficiencies in payment and presentation of court fees.

Judgment source

Supreme Court of India judgment, complete text on Indian Kanoon (unofficial mirror). Open complete decision. No unverified paragraph or bench details are supplied.

Lis pendens and transfers during litigation

Thomson Press (India) Ltd. v. Nanak Builders & Investors (P) Ltd. (2013)

(2013) 5 SCC 397 · Supreme Court of India

Legal issue raised: Can a purchaser during a specific-performance suit be added to the proceedings?

Read complete case analysis

Brief material facts

Property was sold to a third party while the original buyer’s suit for specific performance remained pending.

Judgment and binding principle

The transferee’s purchase did not defeat the pending claim. Impleadment may be allowed to enable an affected transferee to protect its derivative interest, without allowing it to enlarge the vendor’s rights.

Directions or guidelines

No separate generally applicable directions are identified in this case summary. The legal principle above is a statement of the holding, not a court-issued checklist.

Why this precedent matters

A leading link between Section 52 and procedural joinder. Later Supreme Court decisions clarify that joinder is not an unqualified entitlement.

Judgment source

Supreme Court of India judgment, complete text on Indian Kanoon (unofficial mirror). Open complete decision. No unverified paragraph or bench details are supplied.

Lis pendens and transfers during litigation

Chander Bhan v. Mukhtiar Singh (2024)

2024 INSC 377 · Supreme Court of India

Legal issue raised: Whether release and subsequent sale after institution of a specific-performance suit avoid Section 52 through good-faith-purchaser arguments.

Read complete case analysis

Brief material facts

A release deed was executed after an earlier agreement and during litigation. Later purchasers sought Section 41 protection.

Judgment and binding principle

The Court treated the pendente lite release as subject to the suit and rejected the defence based on Section 41 on the facts. The purpose of lis pendens is to preserve effective judicial relief and avert litigation multiplying through alienation.

Directions or guidelines

No separate generally applicable directions are identified in this case summary. The legal principle above is a statement of the holding, not a court-issued checklist.

Why this precedent matters

A 2024 statement connecting Section 52 with the limits of bona fide purchaser protection.

Judgment source

Supreme Court of India judgment, complete text on Indian Kanoon (unofficial mirror). Open complete decision. No unverified paragraph or bench details are supplied.

Lis pendens and transfers during litigation

H. Anjanappa v. A. Prabhakar (2025)

2025 INSC 121 · Supreme Court of India

Legal issue raised: When purchasers during litigation may appeal or seek impleadment after a specific-performance decree.

Read complete case analysis

Brief material facts

Subsequent purchasers acquired portions despite a pending suit and injunction, and later sought leave to appeal a decree despite earlier rejection of their impleadment.

Judgment and binding principle

Transfers pendente lite remain subordinate to the suit. A transferee is not automatically entitled to be joined or to appeal; an appellate court assesses whether a non-party is genuinely aggrieved and prejudicially affected. The Supreme Court allowed the original buyers’ appeals.

Directions or guidelines

The Court summarised that a stranger needs leave and a direct legally prejudicial interest to appeal; joinder of a pendente lite transferee is discretionary, not automatic. Even when absent from the suit, the transferee remains bound by its outcome.

Why this precedent matters

The judgment sets out criteria for leave to appeal and discretionary impleadment. Prior rejection of joinder alone does not answer every leave-to-appeal issue.

Judgment source

Supreme Court of India, official judgment PDF. Open complete decision. No unverified paragraph or bench details are supplied.

Lis pendens and transfers during litigation

Celir LLP v. Sumati Prasad Bafna (2024)

2024 INSC 978 · Supreme Court of India

Legal issue raised: How a Maharashtra-specific amendment requiring registration of notice of lis pendens affects subsequent third-party purchasers.

Read complete case analysis

Brief material facts

A secured-asset auction and later transactions produced contempt and title disputes, including whether a notice of pendency had been registered.

Judgment and binding principle

The Court examined the additional requirement created by the applicable Maharashtra amendment to Section 52. Local statutory conditions may affect the operation of lis pendens; the unamended central rule should not be mechanically substituted.

Directions or guidelines

No separate generally applicable directions are identified in this case summary. The legal principle above is a statement of the holding, not a court-issued checklist.

Why this precedent matters

A careful example of state-specific property law. It also arose within SARFAESI litigation, so do not generalise its result outside those circumstances.

Qualification and subsequent treatment

State amendment and its applicability to the particular property and dates must be checked before reliance.

Judgment source

Supreme Court of India, official judgment PDF. Open complete decision. No unverified paragraph or bench details are supplied.

Lis pendens and transfers during litigation

Alka Shrirang Chavan v. Hemchandra Rajaram Bhonsale (2026)

2026 INSC 52 · Supreme Court of India

Legal issue raised: Can buyers who acquired property during litigation resist execution of the successful claimant’s decree?

Read complete case analysis

Brief material facts

An agreement-to-sell dispute began in 1986. After a decree and court-executed sale deed, later purchasers opposed delivery of possession for decades.

Judgment and binding principle

The Court held that subsequent buyers’ interests were subordinate to the concluded decree. A pendente lite transfer may be valid between its parties, but cannot obstruct enforcement of superior rights determined in litigation. Both appeals were dismissed.

Directions or guidelines

Case-specific Article 142 direction: no further applications or petitions by the named obstructors or persons claiming through them concerning the property were to be entertained. This is not a general prohibition covering unrelated litigants.

Why this precedent matters

A directly relevant 2026 ruling on Section 52 and Order XXI Rules 97 to 102 CPC. The Court also issued case-specific directions to prevent fresh obstruction.

Judgment source

Supreme Court of India, official judgment PDF. Open complete decision. No unverified paragraph or bench details are supplied.

Part performance

Section 53A. Requirements for using a possession-based defence and later registration changes.

Part performance

Nathulal v. Phoolchand (1969)

(1969) 3 SCC 120 · Supreme Court of India

Legal issue raised: When an agreement-holder in possession may rely upon Section 53A and what readiness and willingness require.

Read complete case analysis

Brief material facts

A factory and land were agreed to be sold; possession passed, but completion depended upon the seller obtaining necessary clearances and correcting revenue records.

Judgment and binding principle

For the Section 53A defence, readiness and willingness must be assessed against the contractual sequence of reciprocal obligations. The purchaser was not required to tender performance before the seller completed obligations due first.

Directions or guidelines

No separate generally applicable directions are identified in this case summary. The legal principle above is a statement of the holding, not a court-issued checklist.

Why this precedent matters

Foundational elements of part performance and the correct sequence for evaluating compliance. The decision concerns pre-2001 transactions.

Judgment source

Supreme Court of India judgment, complete text on Indian Kanoon (unofficial mirror). Open complete decision. No unverified paragraph or bench details are supplied.

Part performance

Shrimant Shamrao Suryavanshi v. Pralhad Bhairoba Suryavanshi (2002)

(2002) 3 SCC 676 · Supreme Court of India

Legal issue raised: Whether expiry of the limitation period for specific performance by itself extinguishes a Section 53A defence.

Read complete case analysis

Brief material facts

Transferees who claimed possession under an earlier contract invoked part performance when resisting eviction.

Judgment and binding principle

The Court held that limitation blocking an affirmative suit for specific performance does not by itself defeat an otherwise available defensive plea under Section 53A. The statutory elements must still be met.

Directions or guidelines

No separate generally applicable directions are identified in this case summary. The legal principle above is a statement of the holding, not a court-issued checklist.

Why this precedent matters

A classic contrast between a remedy barred by limitation and a statutory defence. For later agreements, the 2001 registration amendments must also be satisfied.

Judgment source

Supreme Court of India judgment, complete text on Indian Kanoon (unofficial mirror). Open complete decision. No unverified paragraph or bench details are supplied.

Part performance

Rambhau Namdeo Gajre v. Narayan Bapuji Dhotra (2004)

(2004) 8 SCC 614 · Supreme Court of India

Legal issue raised: Can Section 53A be used against the true owner by someone claiming through a separate agreement-holder without title?

Read complete case analysis

Brief material facts

A buyer acquired possession under a second agreement from someone whose own arrangement with the owner had never conveyed ownership.

Judgment and binding principle

Section 53A is a shield against the contracting transferor or those claiming under the transferor, not a new title enforceable generally against strangers. The purchaser lacked the necessary privity and failed to resist the owner’s possession claim.

Directions or guidelines

No separate generally applicable directions are identified in this case summary. The legal principle above is a statement of the holding, not a court-issued checklist.

Why this precedent matters

Frequently examined for the six part-performance conditions and the shield-not-sword principle.

Judgment source

Supreme Court of India judgment, complete text on Indian Kanoon (unofficial mirror). Open complete decision. No unverified paragraph or bench details are supplied.

Part performance

Ameer Minhaj v. Dierdre Elizabeth (Wright) Issar (2018)

(2018) 7 SCC 639 · Supreme Court of India

Legal issue raised: What effect the post-2001 registration rules have on contracts relied upon for protection under Section 53A.

Read complete case analysis

Brief material facts

The dispute included an agreement to sell executed after the Registration and Other Related Laws (Amendment) Act, 2001, along with connected documentary evidence.

Judgment and binding principle

An unregistered post-amendment agreement cannot found the statutory Section 53A defence where Section 17(1A) requires registration. It may still serve another legally permitted evidentiary purpose, including proof of a contract in a specific-performance claim, subject to law.

Directions or guidelines

No separate generally applicable directions are identified in this case summary. The legal principle above is a statement of the holding, not a court-issued checklist.

Why this precedent matters

Essential modern qualification to older part-performance cases. Registration and the date of the agreement are decisive.

Judgment source

Supreme Court of India judgment, complete text on Indian Kanoon (unofficial mirror). Open complete decision. No unverified paragraph or bench details are supplied.

Mortgages and redemption

Sections 58, 60, 69, 76 and 91. Security interests, the right to redeem and clogs on redemption.

Mortgages and redemption

Seth Ganga Dhar v. Shankar Lal (1958)

AIR 1958 SC 770 · Supreme Court of India

Legal issue raised: When mortgage terms restricting redemption amount to a prohibited clog under Section 60.

Read complete case analysis

Brief material facts

A mortgage instrument imposed a very long term before redemption and additional stipulations bearing on the mortgagor’s rights.

Judgment and binding principle

The Court recognised that the right to redeem cannot be defeated through a mortgage bargain. Whether a particular term constitutes a clog requires examination of the transaction, not merely a mechanical assumption based on duration.

Directions or guidelines

No separate generally applicable directions are identified in this case summary. The legal principle above is a statement of the holding, not a court-issued checklist.

Why this precedent matters

Fundamental judicial statement of the equity of redemption. The rule is often expressed as once a mortgage, always a mortgage.

Judgment source

Supreme Court of India judgment, complete text on Indian Kanoon (unofficial mirror). Open complete decision. No unverified paragraph or bench details are supplied.

Mortgages and redemption

Pomal Kanji Govindji v. Vrajlal Karsandas Purohit (1988)

(1989) 1 SCC 458 · Supreme Court of India

Legal issue raised: How courts assess unusually restrictive mortgage conditions and tenancies created by a mortgagee.

Read complete case analysis

Brief material facts

Long-standing mortgage arrangements restricted redemption; additional questions arose concerning persons inducted into possession by mortgagees.

Judgment and binding principle

The Court affirmed that a mortgage exists as security and cannot be transformed by oppressive terms into a practical deprivation of redemption. Terms and lease consequences require examination of the relevant mortgage and tenancy law.

Directions or guidelines

No separate generally applicable directions are identified in this case summary. The legal principle above is a statement of the holding, not a court-issued checklist.

Why this precedent matters

A leading contextual approach to clogs on redemption and related lease consequences.

Judgment source

Supreme Court of India judgment, complete text on Indian Kanoon (unofficial mirror). Open complete decision. No unverified paragraph or bench details are supplied.

Mortgages and redemption

Achaldas Durgaji Oswal v. Ramvilas Gangabisan Heda (2003)

(2003) 3 SCC 614 · Supreme Court of India

Legal issue raised: How usufructuary mortgage terms and limitation interact with the mortgagor’s right to redeem.

Read complete case analysis

Brief material facts

The parties disputed possession and redemption under a long-standing usufructuary mortgage.

Judgment and binding principle

The Supreme Court examined the survival of the equity of redemption in the setting of the mortgage deed and the applicable law. The case is a recognised authority against treating mere continuance of the mortgage as automatic transfer of title to the mortgagee.

Directions or guidelines

No separate generally applicable directions are identified in this case summary. The legal principle above is a statement of the holding, not a court-issued checklist.

Why this precedent matters

Use alongside Singh Ram on limitation and the date the right of redemption accrues; the actual mortgage terms are critical.

Judgment source

Supreme Court of India judgment, complete text on Indian Kanoon (unofficial mirror). Open complete decision. No unverified paragraph or bench details are supplied.

Mortgages and redemption

Singh Ram v. Sheo Ram (2014)

(2014) 9 SCC 185 · Supreme Court of India

Legal issue raised: When limitation begins for redemption of a usufructuary mortgage with no fixed redemption date.

Read complete case analysis

Brief material facts

A larger bench considered inconsistent earlier approaches to when usufructuary mortgagors must sue for redemption.

Judgment and binding principle

For a usufructuary mortgage of the kind considered, the right to seek redemption arises on payment, tender or deposit of the mortgage money, rather than automatically on execution of the mortgage when no time is fixed.

Directions or guidelines

No separate generally applicable directions are identified in this case summary. The legal principle above is a statement of the holding, not a court-issued checklist.

Why this precedent matters

Leading larger-bench authority. Do not apply its limitation rule indiscriminately to simple mortgages or instruments containing distinct stipulations.

Judgment source

Supreme Court of India judgment, complete text on Indian Kanoon (unofficial mirror). Open complete decision. No unverified paragraph or bench details are supplied.

Leases, notice and holding over

Sections 105 to 116. Creation, duration, renewal, notice, forfeiture and possession after expiry.

Leases, notice and holding over

Bhawanji Lakhamshi v. Himatlal Jamnadas Dani (1971)

(1972) 1 SCC 388 · Supreme Court of India

Legal issue raised: What is required for a fresh tenancy by holding over under Section 116.

Read complete case analysis

Brief material facts

After a contractual tenancy ended, the occupant remained in possession in a setting also governed by rent-control legislation.

Judgment and binding principle

Mere continued possession after expiry does not by itself create a renewed contractual tenancy. The lessor’s assent, such as acceptance of rent referable to continuing tenancy, must be established in the statutory setting.

Directions or guidelines

No separate generally applicable directions are identified in this case summary. The legal principle above is a statement of the holding, not a court-issued checklist.

Why this precedent matters

A leading distinction between a tenant holding over and an occupant protected on different statutory grounds.

Judgment source

Supreme Court of India judgment, complete text on Indian Kanoon (unofficial mirror). Open complete decision. No unverified paragraph or bench details are supplied.

Leases, notice and holding over

R.V. Bhupal Prasad v. State of Andhra Pradesh (1995)

(1995) 5 SCC 698 · Supreme Court of India

Legal issue raised: What legal status follows a lease’s expiry when the occupant does not obtain a fresh lease.

Read complete case analysis

Brief material facts

A cinema theatre remained occupied after the agreed twenty-year lease period ended.

Judgment and binding principle

The Court distinguished possession during a subsisting lease from possession after its expiry. Mere physical occupation does not perpetuate an expired tenancy or establish title.

Directions or guidelines

No separate generally applicable directions are identified in this case summary. The legal principle above is a statement of the holding, not a court-issued checklist.

Why this precedent matters

Useful for recognising tenancy at sufferance and identifying when a fresh lease must be affirmatively shown.

Judgment source

Supreme Court of India judgment, complete text on Indian Kanoon (unofficial mirror). Open complete decision. No unverified paragraph or bench details are supplied.

Leases, notice and holding over

Anthony v. K.C. Ittoop & Sons (2000)

(2000) 6 SCC 394 · Supreme Court of India

Legal issue raised: Whether an unregistered document purporting to grant a lease for a term requiring registration precludes every landlord-tenant relationship.

Read complete case analysis

Brief material facts

The tenant occupied a building under a document which should have been registered. The landlord sought eviction and the tenant invoked rent-control protection.

Judgment and binding principle

Failure to register a compulsory registrable lease prevents proof of the term through that instrument, but admitted induction and payment may still establish a tenancy arising independently of the defective deed.

Directions or guidelines

No separate generally applicable directions are identified in this case summary. The legal principle above is a statement of the holding, not a court-issued checklist.

Why this precedent matters

A key distinction between the unenforceability of a stated fixed term and the possible existence of a month-to-month tenancy.

Judgment source

Supreme Court of India judgment, complete text on Indian Kanoon (unofficial mirror). Open complete decision. No unverified paragraph or bench details are supplied.

Leases, notice and holding over

State of U.P. v. Lalji Tandon (2003)

(2004) 1 SCC 1 · Supreme Court of India

Legal issue raised: How renewal differs from extension of a lease and when a fresh deed is necessary.

Read complete case analysis

Brief material facts

The controversy arose over the meaning and operation of a renewal clause in a lease involving State property.

Judgment and binding principle

The Court distinguished a lease extended by its original terms from a lease renewed through a fresh transaction. Depending on the instrument and law, renewal may require execution and registration of a new lease.

Directions or guidelines

No separate generally applicable directions are identified in this case summary. The legal principle above is a statement of the holding, not a court-issued checklist.

Why this precedent matters

Important for drafting and construing renewal clauses rather than treating renewal and extension as interchangeable terms.

Judgment source

Supreme Court of India judgment, complete text on Indian Kanoon (unofficial mirror). Open complete decision. No unverified paragraph or bench details are supplied.

Leases, notice and holding over

K.B. Saha & Sons (P) Ltd. v. Development Consultant Ltd. (2008)

(2008) 8 SCC 564 · Supreme Court of India

Legal issue raised: To what extent an unregistered compulsorily registrable lease can be used to prove its terms.

Read complete case analysis

Brief material facts

The landlord sought to enforce terms in an unregistered lease and relied on the collateral-purpose proviso to registration law.

Judgment and binding principle

The Court limited collateral use of an unregistered instrument. A term directly affecting rights and obligations under the lease cannot be smuggled in as a merely collateral transaction.

Directions or guidelines

No separate generally applicable directions are identified in this case summary. The legal principle above is a statement of the holding, not a court-issued checklist.

Why this precedent matters

A standard authority on Section 107 TPA and Section 49 Registration Act. Always identify the precise purpose for tendering the document.

Judgment source

Supreme Court of India judgment, complete text on Indian Kanoon (unofficial mirror). Open complete decision. No unverified paragraph or bench details are supplied.

Leases, notice and holding over

Nopany Investments (P) Ltd. v. Santokh Singh (HUF) (2007)

(2008) 2 SCC 728 · Supreme Court of India

Legal issue raised: How notice to quit and the general-law eviction remedy operate when rent-control protection no longer applies.

Read complete case analysis

Brief material facts

A tenancy lost the relevant rent statute’s protection after statutory changes and rent enhancement; eviction proceedings followed.

Judgment and binding principle

The Court sustained the landlord’s general-law suit after examining notice and the withdrawal of the rent-control proceedings. The filing of eviction litigation can carry consequences for termination in the circumstances discussed.

Directions or guidelines

No separate generally applicable directions are identified in this case summary. The legal principle above is a statement of the holding, not a court-issued checklist.

Why this precedent matters

Illustrates the interaction between Section 106 and local rent laws; never rely on it without checking current governing State provisions.

Judgment source

Supreme Court of India judgment, complete text on Indian Kanoon (unofficial mirror). Open complete decision. No unverified paragraph or bench details are supplied.

Leases, notice and holding over

Park Street Properties (P) Ltd. v. Dipak Kumar Singh (2016)

(2016) 9 SCC 268 · Supreme Court of India

Legal issue raised: Whether a commercial tenancy could be terminated by fifteen days’ notice under Section 106 despite an alleged longer commercial arrangement.

Read complete case analysis

Brief material facts

The premises were used for a restaurant. The tenants relied on business arrangements and rent-escalation terms to contest termination.

Judgment and binding principle

The Supreme Court upheld termination under Section 106 on the particular contract and facts. A supposed contract to the contrary must be legally valid and actually displace the statutory default, rather than merely be inferred from commercial expectations.

Directions or guidelines

No separate generally applicable directions are identified in this case summary. The legal principle above is a statement of the holding, not a court-issued checklist.

Why this precedent matters

Useful for notice-to-quit drafting and the limits of informal promises about tenancy duration.

Judgment source

Supreme Court of India judgment, complete text on Indian Kanoon (unofficial mirror). Open complete decision. No unverified paragraph or bench details are supplied.

Gifts, settlement and Muslim-law hiba

Sections 122 to 129. Acceptance, transfer of possession, revocation and personal-law exceptions.

Gifts, settlement and Muslim-law hiba

K. Balakrishnan v. K. Kamalam (2003)

(2004) 1 SCC 581 · Supreme Court of India

Legal issue raised: Can a minor accept a gift and may the donor retain possession and enjoyment during life?

Read complete case analysis

Brief material facts

A mother gifted property interests to her young children but reserved lifetime management and income. She later attempted to cancel the gift.

Judgment and binding principle

A minor may accept a beneficial gift, expressly or through circumstances. Reserving lifetime enjoyment does not necessarily prevent immediate transfer of title. Once a valid gift has been accepted, Section 126 controls revocation.

Directions or guidelines

No separate generally applicable directions are identified in this case summary. The legal principle above is a statement of the holding, not a court-issued checklist.

Why this precedent matters

Leading decision on gifts to minors and permissible lifetime reservations.

Judgment source

Supreme Court of India judgment, complete text on Indian Kanoon (unofficial mirror). Open complete decision. No unverified paragraph or bench details are supplied.

Gifts, settlement and Muslim-law hiba

Asokan v. Lakshmikutty (2007)

(2007) 13 SCC 210 · Supreme Court of India

Legal issue raised: How the donee’s acceptance of a gift under Section 122 may be proved.

Read complete case analysis

Brief material facts

The dispute concerned whether recitals and surrounding conduct established that a gift had actually been accepted.

Judgment and binding principle

The statute does not prescribe one exclusive manner of acceptance. Possession, delivery of the deed and conduct may establish acceptance, but the question remains factual and must be decided from the circumstances.

Directions or guidelines

No separate generally applicable directions are identified in this case summary. The legal principle above is a statement of the holding, not a court-issued checklist.

Why this precedent matters

Useful for distinguishing execution from completion of a gift. The donee’s acceptance during the donor’s lifetime remains indispensable.

Judgment source

Supreme Court of India judgment, complete text on Indian Kanoon (unofficial mirror). Open complete decision. No unverified paragraph or bench details are supplied.

Gifts, settlement and Muslim-law hiba

Hafeeza Bibi v. Shaikh Farid (2011)

(2011) 5 SCC 654 · Supreme Court of India

Legal issue raised: Whether Muslim-law hiba requires a registered instrument merely because a written memorandum exists.

Read complete case analysis

Brief material facts

A family property dispute involved an asserted Muslim gift and questions concerning written records and registration.

Judgment and binding principle

Section 129 preserves the applicable rules of Muhammadan law. A valid hiba ordinarily requires declaration, acceptance and delivery of possession as recognised by that law; writing is not invariably essential, and a record of a completed oral gift is distinct from an instrument itself creating one.

Directions or guidelines

No separate generally applicable directions are identified in this case summary. The legal principle above is a statement of the holding, not a court-issued checklist.

Why this precedent matters

Important personal-law exception to the general Section 123 requirement. The specific character of the writing must be examined.

Judgment source

Supreme Court of India judgment, complete text on Indian Kanoon (unofficial mirror). Open complete decision. No unverified paragraph or bench details are supplied.

Gifts, settlement and Muslim-law hiba

Renikuntla Rajamma v. K. Sarwanamma (2014)

(2014) 9 SCC 445 · Supreme Court of India

Legal issue raised: Is physical delivery of possession essential to complete a registered gift of immovable property?

Read complete case analysis

Brief material facts

A donor gifted ownership but reserved the right to enjoy the property during her lifetime, and later purported to revoke the gift.

Judgment and binding principle

A duly executed, attested and registered gift of immovable property, accepted during the donor’s lifetime, is not invalid merely because actual possession remains with the donor. The Court distinguished the conditional, unaccepted gift in Naramadaben.

Directions or guidelines

No separate generally applicable directions are identified in this case summary. The legal principle above is a statement of the holding, not a court-issued checklist.

Why this precedent matters

A three-judge statement reconciling earlier opinions on Sections 122 and 123. It remains central to drafting lifetime-interest settlements.

Judgment source

Supreme Court of India judgment, complete text on Indian Kanoon (unofficial mirror). Open complete decision. No unverified paragraph or bench details are supplied.

Gifts, settlement and Muslim-law hiba

N.P. Saseendran v. N.P. Ponnamma (2025)

2025 INSC 388 · Supreme Court of India

Legal issue raised: How to distinguish a present gift or settlement reserving a life interest from a testamentary disposition.

Read complete case analysis

Brief material facts

A father executed a 1985 deed in favour of his daughter but retained a lifetime interest. He later attempted cancellation and sold the property to his son.

Judgment and binding principle

The Court interpreted the deed as transferring an interest in praesenti, although enjoyment was reserved for life. The deed was a settlement/gift, not merely a will; unilateral cancellation and the later sale were ineffective. The appeal was dismissed.

Directions or guidelines

No separate generally applicable directions are identified in this case summary. The legal principle above is a statement of the holding, not a court-issued checklist.

Why this precedent matters

A recent official ruling on substance over labels when construing family settlement deeds. Acceptance may be inferred from the circumstances.

Judgment source

Supreme Court of India, official judgment PDF. Open complete decision. No unverified paragraph or bench details are supplied.

Assignment and actionable claims

Sections 5, 6 and 130 in context. Assignment of financial debts, securities and related banking law.

Assignment and actionable claims

ICICI Bank Ltd. v. Official Liquidator of APS Star Industries Ltd. (2010)

(2010) 10 SCC 1 · Supreme Court of India

Legal issue raised: Whether inter-bank assignments of debts and non-performing assets are lawful banking transactions.

Read complete case analysis

Brief material facts

Banks assigned outstanding loan debts and underlying securities, prompting challenges in company-liquidation proceedings.

Judgment and binding principle

The Court rejected the proposition that genuine transfers of NPAs between banks were necessarily prohibited banking business. A bank may assign its debt asset with related security in accordance with the governing banking and transfer law.

Directions or guidelines

No separate generally applicable directions are identified in this case summary. The legal principle above is a statement of the holding, not a court-issued checklist.

Why this precedent matters

Important for receivables and mortgage-backed debt assignments; banking-regulatory rules and the actual assignment instrument must also be checked.

Judgment source

Supreme Court of India, official judgment PDF. Open complete decision. No unverified paragraph or bench details are supplied.

Research, coverage and limitations

Research cut-off: 16 November 2026. This compilation selects foundational and comparatively recent Supreme Court decisions involving central doctrines of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882. Decisions are grouped by subject rather than chronology. Citation formats reflect the available reporter or official neutral citations.

Official Supreme Court PDFs are linked for selected recent judgments and the assignment case. Older judgments use publicly accessible full-text Indian Kanoon mirrors, which are not official court publications. The summaries are original editorial analyses, not substitutes for checking the judgment text. Earlier holdings must be read with subsequent amendments, particularly the 2001 registration changes affecting Section 53A, and any applicable State modifications to Section 52 and tenancy legislation.

This is a substantial selection, not a claim to include every important reported case. Sections on perpetuity and vested interests, priority and fraudulent transfers, detailed charges, exchange, and several actionable-claim provisions need additional primary-source verification before being called exhaustively covered. Direct judgments may change their hosting addresses over time. No Supreme Court website, LawFoyer website or WordPress installation has been modified.

Statutory starting point: India Code official legislative portal. Always verify amendments and the version applicable to the transaction date.

Share this :
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
WhatsApp